World News Insights
1-3 Minute Gist

All Topics Article

Austerity Debate a Matter of Degree

Wall Street Journal Original article ›

Keywords:

LyrArc Article Gist
The IMF's changing views on the value of fiscal austerity. In the current debate about the value of fiscal austerity, there is the IMF view, a German view based on its own experience, and the views of other countries in Europe. The IMF's view has shifted over time. The IMF World Economic Outlook 2010, describes its view of the effects of austerity measures in the form of spending cuts and tax increases- "Fiscal consolidation typically has a contractionary effect on output. A fiscal consolidation equal to 1% of GDP typically reduces GDP by about 0.5% within 2 years and raises the unemployment rate by about 0.3% percentage points." Over the longer term there are benefits as the private sector is not crowded out in the search for captal funding by the excessive government borrowing. The IMF's economic models suggest that it would take 5 years before reaching the breakeven point when the benefits of austerity measures exceed the effects of austerity. The German view held by German central bankers is that the actions stimulate growth in the short term. Manfred Neumann, professor emeritus at the Institute for Economic Policy at the University of Bonn, says this is called the "German hypothesis" as it reflects the experience of Germany from austerity actions taken by Germany. Laurence Ball, professor of Economics at John Hopkins University, is critical of the "German hypothesis" and its application across Europe in different situations. Germany is a large exporting nation and exports helped counterbalance the effects of austerity measures. Within the eurozone with fixed exchange rates the exports of less competitive countries cannot be boosted through devaluing the currency to gain price competitiveness. The other problem is that with interest rates close to zero in the euro zone the central banks cannot cut rates aggressively to counteract the effects of spending cuts. The problem gets compounded when a number of countries are taking austerity measures at the same time accentuating the downturn.

IMF in the Eurozone financial crisis of 2010-2012

03/03/2010

Aid package to Greece and funds for other eurozone countries. The IMF's involvement in protecting the eurozone.

Grouped Articles

A Warning Light to Alert the I.M.F.

New York Times 09/21/2011

EU Dismisses IMF's Criticism On Greek Bailout

Wall Street Journal 06/07/2013

Policy ‘Troika’ for Europe Financial Woes at Odds

New York Times 06/07/2013

Europe's Original Sin

Wall Street Journal 03/03/2010

Greece Can Learn IMF Austerity from Turkey

BusinessWeek 05/27/2010

Past Rifts Over Greece Cloud Talks on Rescue

Wall Street Journal 10/07/2013

IMF management- 2011-2015

05/18/2011

Grouped Articles

Congress Can Help the U.S. By Reforming The IMF

Wall Street Journal 03/25/2014

The U.S. Should Ratify Its Agreement to IMF Reform

Wall Street Journal 04/02/2014

Congress passes budget deal and heads home for the year - The Washington Post

Washington Post 12/19/2015

Acting Head Faces Host of Challenges

Wall Street Journal 05/18/2011

Economist's Rise on World Stage Was Marked by Repeated Setbacks

Wall Street Journal 05/20/2011

How the Strauss-Kahn Case Damages Europe

BusinessWeek 05/18/2011

The IMF and Italy

11/04/2011

Grouped Articles

Italy Agrees to Allow I.M.F. to Monitor Its Progress on Debt

New York Times 11/04/2011

Ailing Italy Accepts IMF Monitoring

Wall Street Journal 11/05/2011

Exit From Italian Debt Spurs Fears

Wall Street Journal 11/09/2011

Austerity Debate a Matter of Degree

Wall Street Journal 02/17/2012

Italy faces another year of recession as capital drains - The Washington Post

Washington Post 07/11/2012

Britain's new 2010 Budget marks a big change from the past.

05/13/2010

The UK Chancellor of the Exchequer, George Osborne, put forward a budget with a 25% spending cut by 2015 in all departments except health and international aid. This marks a huge departure in years of spending by the Labor governments. The new Conservative-Liberal coalition government is determined to take austerity measures to reduce the national debt.

Grouped Articles

Britain's accidental revolution

Economist 05/13/2010

U-Turn in the U.K.: Big Spending Cuts

Wall Street Journal 10/14/2010

Britain Details Radical Spending Cuts, Citing Debt

New York Times 10/20/2010

U.K. Plans New Taxes on Banks, Multinationals

Wall Street Journal 12/04/2014

Tough Slog to Balancing U.K.’s Budget

Wall Street Journal 12/04/2014

Overheard: Digging for Answers on Coal

Wall Street Journal 03/29/2015

Italy, Spain and austerity measures- 2011-2013

08/08/2011

Analysts point to the austerity measures adopted by Italy and Spain much earlier than other countries in the eurozone. The risk now is cutting into muscle as growth for 2011 is expected to be below 1% in both countries. Italy say analysts is actually in surplus when the interest on debt is excluded.

Grouped Articles

Italy Urged to Resist a Relapse in Spending

Wall Street Journal 05/03/2013

Still Sputtering, Spain Turns Away From Cuts

Wall Street Journal 05/12/2013

German Election Overturns Political Order

Wall Street Journal 09/23/2013

Those Depressing Germans

New York Times 11/03/2013

Saying No to Austerity, Spain Unveils Tax Cuts

New York Times 06/20/2014

European Finance Ministers Support Investment Program

New York Times 09/14/2014

Portugal's austerity measures and the financial crisis 2010-2015

09/27/2010

Collapse of the government in Portugal in 2011, after failing to win support for further austerity measures.

Grouped Articles

Portugal Unveils Budget Cuts

Wall Street Journal 05/03/2013

Portugal Returns to Bond Market

Wall Street Journal 05/08/2013

Portugal Plans Cuts in Spending

Wall Street Journal 05/30/2013

Portugal's Government Thrust Into Turmoil

Wall Street Journal 07/03/2013

Lisbon Cabinet Shuffle Buoys Junior Coalition Party Leader

Wall Street Journal 07/08/2013

Portugal’s President Calls for Early Elections

New York Times 07/11/2013

Romania's austerity measures 2009-2013

02/07/2012

Grouped Articles

Favorite Concedes Presidency in Romania

New York Times 11/16/2014

Protests Drive Out Romania Premier

Wall Street Journal 02/07/2012

Austerity Debate a Matter of Degree

Wall Street Journal 02/17/2012

Pain Without Gain

New York Times 02/19/2012

Death of a Fairy Tale

New York Times 04/26/2012

Vote in Romania Fells Government

Wall Street Journal 04/28/2012

The focus on competitiveness by economists, credit ratings agencies, and European leaders as austerity measures alone won't work

02/05/2011

Mario Monti focusses on the need for investing in the economy in an interview with German newspaper Die Welt during a January 2011 visit to Berlin. S&P economists and Nobel winner Stiglitz also emphasize this after a downgrade of France's credit rating- the need for improved competitiveness for the economies of France, Spain Portugal and Italy.

Grouped Articles

Euro Zone Death Trip

New York Times 09/25/2011

The Emperor Creates No Jobs

Wall Street Journal 05/29/2013

The Next First (and Only) 100 Days

New York Times 12/10/2011

A Proud Nation Ponders How to Halt Its Slow Decline

New York Times 08/24/2013

After a Recession in Portugal, the Tiny Green Fruits of Success

New York Times 08/28/2013

France Says It Will Miss Budget Deficit Targets

Wall Street Journal 09/12/2013

The impact of austerity measures on various parts of Britain.

07/03/2010

Impact of the Cameron government spending cuts across the UK.

Grouped Articles

U.K. Politicians Vie to Address Fall in Living Standards

Wall Street Journal 11/18/2013

British Towns and Institutions Reel From First Austerity Cuts

New York Times 08/09/2010

Radical Britain: The unlikely revolutionary

Economist 08/14/2010

As the Working Poor Become More Common in Britain, So Does Hunger

New York Times 01/02/2014

U-Turn in the U.K.: Big Spending Cuts

Wall Street Journal 10/14/2010

Jack Monroe Has Become Britain’s Austerity Celebrity

New York Times 01/14/2014

President Obama's U.S. Budget for fiscal 2012

02/10/2011

Grouped Articles

Budget Shell Games Are Contrary to Law

Wall Street Journal 07/14/2011

Obama's Budget: Something for Everyone to Hate

BusinessWeek 02/10/2011

Obama Budget Said to Trim Deficit by $1.1 Trillion

New York Times 02/12/2011

Budget Plan Marks Start of Long Fight on Spending

Wall Street Journal 02/14/2011

Voters Balk at Cuts Close to Home

Wall Street Journal 02/15/2011

The risk of an American government shutdown: Time to stop play-acting and spit out the tea

Economist 04/02/2011

What does Germany want from the Euro and the European Union? The Euro issue facing Germany in 2011-2015

03/03/2010

German political leaders do not want a "transfer union." At the same time they want to keep the European Union, just as much as Chancellor Kohl and Chancellor Adenauer. Merkel, Schroeder, Schauble and other leaders agree on the need for the European Union. The question is how to bring fiscal discipline to the EU, even if this means redesigning the structure of the EU. The vision of a united Europe persists.

Grouped Articles

Europe's Original Sin

Wall Street Journal 03/03/2010

Germany's Surplus Isn't the Problem

Wall Street Journal 11/11/2013

Crisis of the Eurocrats

New York Times 05/22/2014

Greek Crisis Shows How Germany’s Power Polarizes Europe

Wall Street Journal 07/07/2015

Strict order

Economist 08/08/2015

Charlemagne: Germany’s euro question

Economist 09/10/2011

A warning light for Greece to exit the eurozone and return to the drachma to restore competitiveness and growth 2011-2012

05/26/2010

Greece needs to lower prices by 31% just to get to the level of Turkey, says the head of the Ifo research institute in Germany, Wener Sinn. Experts fear a breakdown in civil order inside Greece if deflation at this level occurs with Greece still using the euro. Hollande, the Socialist party candidate in France, also expressed similiar concerns, as reported in the New York Times, calling it a breakup in European governance that followed the breakdown in Greek governance. Sinn says the bondholders are overly exaggerating the risks of a breakup in the eurozone if Greece exits the euro.

Grouped Articles

Germany reaps rewards of entitlement cuts - The Washington Post

Washington Post 09/20/2011

Euro Zone Death Trip

New York Times 09/25/2011

Germany vs. Europe

New York Times 05/26/2010

New Attempt at French-German Amity Stumbles in Venice

Wall Street Journal 08/21/2013

German Election Overturns Political Order

Wall Street Journal 09/23/2013

Departing EADS Chief Urges Europe to Recommit to Industry

New York Times 04/12/2012

Antonis Samaras of Greece's New Democracy Party and the European Union programs for Greece

07/05/2011

Samaras says the tax increases will hurt the Greece economy and the shrinking Greek economy under the current program will lead to the failure of the E.U.'s program for Greece.

Grouped Articles

EU Dismisses IMF's Criticism On Greek Bailout

Wall Street Journal 06/07/2013

Only Syriza Can Save Greece

New York Times 06/23/2013

Fractious Greek Government Splits

Wall Street Journal 06/25/2013

Greek Draft Budget Sees Primary Surplus, Return to Growth

Wall Street Journal 10/14/2013

Athens's Love Affair With the Euro Persists

Wall Street Journal 11/04/2013

Next Hurdle for Greece's Economy: Its Own Political Uncertainty

New York Times 10/13/2014

Debt Restructuring for Greece- 2010-2012

04/18/2011

Grouped Articles

Policy ‘Troika’ for Europe Financial Woes at Odds

New York Times 06/07/2013

Watch Athens, Not Paris, This Weekend

Wall Street Journal 05/04/2012

Expectations Grow for Greek Debt Restructuring

New York Times 04/18/2011

None Dare Call It Default

Wall Street Journal 04/20/2011

Investors Doubt Orthodoxy on Greek Debt

Wall Street Journal 05/02/2011

Greek Debt Talks Widen Divisions in the Euro Zone

Wall Street Journal 05/05/2011

Faces of recession battered Greece as new austerity programs are adopted by the government

06/28/2011

Grouped Articles

EU Dismisses IMF's Criticism On Greek Bailout

Wall Street Journal 06/07/2013

Those Depressing Germans

New York Times 11/03/2013

Greece’s prescription for a health-care crisis - The Washington Post

Washington Post 02/22/2014

Across Athens, Graffiti Worth a Thousand Words of Malaise

New York Times 04/15/2014

Greek Patience With Austerity Nears Its Limit

New York Times 12/29/2014

Greece’s new prime minister wants Germany to pay for Nazi war crimes - The Washington Post

Washington Post 01/26/2015

A Brady Plan type solution for the debt crises in Greece, Ireland, Portugal and other EU countries.

05/18/2010

Grouped Articles

EU Dismisses IMF's Criticism On Greek Bailout

Wall Street Journal 06/07/2013

Personalities Clashing Over How to Handle New Greek Bailout

New York Times 07/23/2015

Nervous Europe Trying to Halt Economic Crisis

New York Times 11/30/2010

Europe's Central Banker Seeks Deeper Fiscal Union

Wall Street Journal 06/03/2011

'Contagion' and Other Euro Myths

Wall Street Journal 12/02/2010

Greek Myths and the Euro Tragedy

Wall Street Journal 05/18/2010

Greece, debt and the new austerity budgets 2011-2013

12/10/2009

Grouped Articles

Greek Draft Budget Sees Primary Surplus, Return to Growth

Wall Street Journal 10/14/2013

Greek Patience With Austerity Nears Its Limit

New York Times 12/29/2014

Greece’s new prime minister wants Germany to pay for Nazi war crimes - The Washington Post

Washington Post 01/26/2015

Greece Wanted to Reframe Europe’s Austerity Debate. It Failed.

New York Times 07/01/2015

Mirage of Economic Turnaround Masked New Greek Crisis in the Making

Wall Street Journal 07/05/2015

Greece: Austerity Budget Passed

New York Times 12/25/2009

Greece: prospect of default on debt.

12/29/2009

Grouped Articles

Greece Defaults on IMF Loan Despite New Push for Bailout Aid

Wall Street Journal 07/01/2015

Greece, Missing I.M.F. Payment, Is Called Effectively in Default

New York Times 06/30/2015

SPIEGEL ONLINE - Druckversion - Euro under Threat: Culture of Corruption Drags Greece Down - SPIEGEL ONLINE - News - International

Unknown 12/29/2009

SPIEGEL ONLINE - Druckversion - No IMF Aid Expected for Greece: EU to Solve Financial Fiasco Alone - SPIEGEL ONLINE - News - International

Unknown 12/29/2009

The Worst May Not Be Over for Europe

New York Times 12/31/2009

The Making of a Euromess

New York Times 02/15/2010

Lack of competitiveness in the economy of Greece

01/29/2011

Grouped Articles

Euro Zone Death Trip

New York Times 09/25/2011

In Greece, a Brewer'€s Dream Runs Into Frustration

New York Times 01/29/2011

Gap in Competitiveness Weighs on Europe, Analysts Say

New York Times 01/15/2012

Greek Premier Is Tested in Impasse Over Pay Cuts

New York Times 02/03/2012

The Chaos of Greece

Wall Street Journal 02/14/2012

Germany's Inflated Fear of Inflation

Wall Street Journal 02/14/2012

Simon Johnson and other experts on the debt crisis in Europe.

04/15/2010

Simon Johnson, Peter Boone and other experts unravel the debt crisis in Greece and in other European countries to give a lucid explanation of what happened and what to expect.

Grouped Articles

Can Europe Save Itself?

New York Times 04/29/2010

Greece, the Latest and Greatest Bubble.

New York Times 04/29/2010

As Greek Drama Plays Out, Where Is Europe?

New York Times 04/29/2010

The Euro Trap

New York Times 04/30/2010

Too Big to Prevail?

BusinessWeek 04/15/2010

The cracks spread and widen

Economist 04/29/2010

John Cochrane and other experts give a no-nonsense view of the bailouts and the financial crises facing Europe

12/02/2010

Insights that the real problem is short term debt financing. The need for the EU to insist on long tem debt financing for governments in Europe. The solution for this crisis is not in bailouts of Greece, Spain, Italy and so on, but to swap the short term debt for debt with longer term maturities, and for bondholders to take a haircut. Similiar to the Brady Plan for Latin America in the late 1980's. The bailout of Ireland in reality not a bailout of Ireland, as a bailout of German and British banks that made risky loans to Irish banks and the Irish government. The U.S. government's debt also tilted to short term debt and problems similar to European problems.

Grouped Articles

EU Dismisses IMF's Criticism On Greek Bailout

Wall Street Journal 06/07/2013

'Contagion' and Other Euro Myths

Wall Street Journal 12/02/2010

As Ireland Flails, Europe Lurches Across the Rubicon

Wall Street Journal 12/27/2010

Running the euro zone: Pact of uncompetitiveness

Economist 02/12/2011

Europe's Banking Blindfolds

Wall Street Journal 03/11/2011

Europe Needs to Apportion Pain

Wall Street Journal 03/17/2011

Similarities between the experience of Argentina in 2001 and the experience of Greece, Ireland, Portugal and Spain in 2010-2012

12/09/2010

The financial crisis in the euro-zone and a similar situation that prevailed in Argentina in 2001. Experts from that period are convinced that euro-zone bondholders will have to accept securities offering less interest and maturing over a longer period.

Grouped Articles

Greek Government Bonds Pay Off Big for Fund Managers

Wall Street Journal 10/28/2013

Argentine Farmers Reap Discontent

Wall Street Journal 05/29/2014

What Greece Faces if It Defaults

New York Times 04/29/2015

If Greece Defaults, Imagine Argentina, but Much Worse

New York Times 06/25/2015

The Argentina Veterans Eye the Euro Warily

BusinessWeek 12/09/2010

Government debt: Behold 2011, the year of sovereign shocks

Economist 12/18/2010

The 2010 austerity budget and the European financial crisis affecting Spain.

05/13/2010

The contagion effect affecting Spain after Greece and Portugal similar to the manner in which the Asian financial crisis spread during a prior decade.

Grouped Articles

New Spanish Budget Free of Austerity Measures

New York Times 09/27/2013

Saying No to Austerity, Spain Unveils Tax Cuts

New York Times 06/20/2014

Spain is simply shifting the problem

Wall Street Journal 05/14/2010

Amid Europe's challenges, citizens face lifestyle shifts

Wall Street Journal 05/14/2010

French Cracks Are Showing in Euro-Zone Core

Wall Street Journal 05/13/2010

The IMF's Big Wager On Europe

Wall Street Journal 05/13/2010

Britain's perilous path with austerity cuts, inflation and lower economic growth- 2011-2015

06/22/2010

Grouped Articles

The economy: On a wing and a credit card

Economist 07/08/2013

U.K. Moves To Tackle Income Squeeze

Wall Street Journal 08/20/2013

The Curious Case of Britain's Economic Recovery

Wall Street Journal 10/21/2013

U.K. Politicians Vie to Address Fall in Living Standards

Wall Street Journal 11/18/2013

U.K. Government Prepares For Deep Budget Cuts

Wall Street Journal 06/22/2010

British Towns and Institutions Reel From First Austerity Cuts

New York Times 08/09/2010

The growing debate over bondholder haircut, easy money policies, sacrifices, and austerity policies.

11/25/2010

This debate puts British prime minister Cameron, and German chancellor Angela Merkel, on one side, with US President Obama, US central bank chairman Bernanke and other leaders on the other side. The blanket Irish guarantee of all Irish bank debt is an example of improper action that could have prevented the need for an Irish bailout, when guaranteeing only retail Irish bank debt would have worked. Merkel has insisted on bondholders sharing in bank losses, and tougher action required for countries receiving bailouts.

Grouped Articles

A Crisis Needing More Sacrifice

New York Times 11/25/2010

Crises Shake German Trust in Euro Zone

New York Times 11/26/2010

EU Outlines Bond Restructuring Plan

Wall Street Journal 11/28/2010

Europe Backs Irish Rescue and New Rules on Bailouts

New York Times 11/28/2010

Spain, Italy Seek Action

Wall Street Journal 12/02/2010

'Contagion' and Other Euro Myths

Wall Street Journal 12/02/2010


Support LyrArc

We took a different way to help millions around the world build educated informed mindsets that affects and shapes their lives. For a future that is open, global and digital, with everyone having access to high quality information. We believe in the renewal of America, renewal of Europe, the renewal of India, the rest of Asia, Latin America and Africa. The renewal of our supply chains, health, education, infrastructure, as we rebuild our countries after the pandemic. Literacy and knowledge we believe cannot thrive and grow in a world of web bots, web crawlers, or AI. This requires human curiosity, human learning, and human imagination. We take as inspiration the saying- “One has to be free, and as broad as sky. One has to have a mind that is crystal clear, only then can truth shine in it.” Every contribution whether big or small is precious- in this crisis and ahead.

Support Lyrarc from as small as $1


Copyright © 2006 - 2026 Intelilinks LLC
Terms and Conditions | Copyright Policy | Privacy Policy | Contact Us