World News Insights
1-3 Minute Gist

All Topics Article

Chinese debt: The great hole of China

Economist Original article ›

Keywords:

LyrArc Article Gist
The Economist points out that China's total debt of government, corporate and households has grown by about 100% of GDP since 2008. The 2009 crisis led to rapid increase in debt. It is now about 250% of GDP, according to the Economist. Slower growth of below 7% risks reducing China's ability to service this debt. About half of this debt is owed by state owned companies and property developers. China can use its sovereign reserves to continue supporting bank and state owned companies. Investor's are pricing bank shares to reflect about 10% of this debt as bad debt even though government estimates are much lower. The reserves provided China time to fix the banking system since 2008, yet the debt keeps growing and China has failed to take strong action in the last 6 years. Complacency is a problem, and the incentives for local governments to continue prior practices that increase debt continue. As Krugman and other experts have pointed out at some point the rules of finance will apply to China as they have for other countries that faced a debt crisis- Japan in the late 1980's, South Korea and other Aisan countries in 1997, and the U.S. in 2008. Even without a crisis through deft managemen and use of reserves China risks zombifying the economy as old loans are backed up by new loans, with the further risk of misallocation of capital or poor use of capital. This lowers productivity of capital and hurts development. With poor statistics such as the figure of 1% of debt being bad debt cited here, the problems of complacency can be magnified, as there is less reason for a strong response.

China's debt situation in 2014 with total debt to GDP of 250%, and the risks to the economy

10/17/2014

Grouped Articles

Chinese debt: The great hole of China

Economist 10/17/2014

The End of China’s Economic Miracle?

Wall Street Journal 11/24/2014

China Lowers Growth Target to About 7%

Wall Street Journal 03/05/2015

China’s Stock-Market Boom Won’t Erase Bad Debts

Wall Street Journal 05/13/2015

China’s Economy Not Immune to Market Sickness

Wall Street Journal 06/30/2015

Devaluation Hints at China’s Rising Distress Over Economy

New York Times 08/12/2015

Build transfer transactions accounting for 40% of the 67% growth in China's local government debt for 2010-2013

05/19/2014

The rapid growth of build transfer transactions which are not properly regulated and now account for 16% of local government debt from 10% in 2010. The conncection between local government debt, shadow banking and housing construction in China.

Grouped Articles

China's Debt Risks Come to Fore in Housing Project

Wall Street Journal 05/19/2014

Chinese debt: The great hole of China

Economist 10/17/2014

China’s Shadow-Banking Boom Is Over

Wall Street Journal 12/24/2014

Debt That Once Boosted Its Cities Now Burdens China

Wall Street Journal 01/28/2015

Small is ugly

Economist 07/04/2015

A Warning on China Seems Prescient

New York Times 08/24/2015

China's local government debt poses a risk for the economy

06/17/2010

China's local government debt is estimated to be in the range of 27% to 42% of GDP. Loans by banks to local government financing vehicles face high risk of default.

Grouped Articles

Asia Goes on a Debt Binge as Much of World Sobers Up

Wall Street Journal 05/24/2013

China's 'Shadow Banks' Fan Debt-Bubble Fears

Wall Street Journal 06/24/2013

China's Silver Linings Playbook

Wall Street Journal 06/24/2013

I.M.F. Tells China of Urgent Need for Economic Change

New York Times 07/17/2013

China's Credit Levels Echo U.S. Crisis

Wall Street Journal 09/08/2013

China Think Tank Offers Reform Wish List

Wall Street Journal 10/30/2013

Financial strength of companies in China's solar power sector 2013-2014

09/01/2011

Smaller solar firms are on a better financial footing than larger companies with a lot of debt.

Grouped Articles

The Man at the Center of Solar-Panel Maker Suntech's Fall

Wall Street Journal 05/03/2013

EU to Slap Tariffs on Chinese Solar Panels

Wall Street Journal 05/07/2013

EU Plans Tariffs of Up to 67.9% on Chinese Solar Panels

Wall Street Journal 05/08/2013

U.S. Solar Company Bankruptcies a Boon for China

New York Times 09/01/2011

The Global Solar Cartel

Wall Street Journal 05/24/2013

Dark Times Fall on Solar Sector

Wall Street Journal 12/27/2011

Fitch Ratings analyst Charlene Chu's analysis of China's shadow banking and unreported private debt

08/01/2010

CHina's private debt is over twice China's GDP according to Fitch Ratings analyst Charlene Chu

Grouped Articles

Charlene Chu Is the 'Rock Star' of Chinese Debt Analysis

Wall Street Journal 08/22/2013

China's Credit Levels Echo U.S. Crisis

Wall Street Journal 09/08/2013

Heard on the Street: Shadow Boxing With Risk at Chinese Banks

Wall Street Journal 09/22/2013

China Think Tank Offers Reform Wish List

Wall Street Journal 10/30/2013

China’s Real Estate Boom and Conflicting Policy

New York Times 08/01/2010

Xi Faces Test Over China's Local Debt

Wall Street Journal 12/31/2013

Needed changes in China under the Jinping-Keqiang administration- China's pension system and version of Social Security

02/18/2013

A patchwork of local programs run by 2500 county and city governments, more like what existed in the U.S. before FDR's New Deal, is how an expert on pensions in China describes the situation in 2013. Urban pensions have existed since 1951, rural pensions were introduced in 2009. The National Social Security Fund is only partly funded with $140 billion. Local governments taking on large levels of debt, shifting funds to risky investments, and benefitting well connected groups, is a risk for pension funds at the local level. By 2030 the number of rural people depending on the pension program is likely to double, says Frazier, creating a new challenge. A challenge made more acute by the one child policy and retirement for men at 60 and women at 55 years of age, reducing productive workers to support rising population of elderly.

Grouped Articles

Aging Chinese Face a Bleak Picture

Wall Street Journal 05/31/2013

China's Zhejiang Becomes First Province to Loosen Family-Planning Policy

Wall Street Journal 01/20/2014

At China's NPC, Proposed Changes Include Bank Deposit Insurance

Wall Street Journal 03/06/2014

Chinese debt: The great hole of China

Economist 10/17/2014

China lifts one-child policy amid worries over graying population - The Washington Post

Washington Post 10/29/2015

No Country for Old Age

New York Times 02/18/2013

China Stimulus Spending and investment in infrastructure- 2008-2011

08/02/2008

China's efforts to revive its economy with a large Stimulus Spending Plan.

Grouped Articles

Can China Cool Its Economy?

BusinessWeek 04/14/2010

Fixing a Perception Gap for the Underappreciated G-20

Wall Street Journal 08/27/2013

China’s Dollar Trap

New York Times 04/03/2009

Chinese debt: The great hole of China

Economist 10/17/2014

China’s Economic Stress Test

Wall Street Journal 08/25/2015

China Lets Banks Lend 5% More This Year

Wall Street Journal 08/02/2008

China's fiscal 2014 budget plans and spending priorities set at the National People's Congress (NPC) in 2014

03/08/2013

Increase in the budget deficit by 12.5% to meet spending priortities in the areas of job growth, healthcare, military spending, and tackling pollution.

Grouped Articles

China Expects Larger Budget Deficit

Wall Street Journal 03/06/2014

Its Growth Targets Elusive, China Focuses on Jobs and Quality of Life

New York Times 03/13/2014

Smog Clears on China Energy Reform

Wall Street Journal 03/08/2013

For Xi, a 'China Dream' of Military Power

Wall Street Journal 03/13/2013

In China, Beijing Fights Losing Battle to Rein In Factory Production

Wall Street Journal 07/16/2014

Chinese Steel Expert- N Way Out for Mills Caught in Crackdown

Wall Street Journal 07/16/2014

China's health care reforms and increased spending on health care fall short of what is needed.

12/30/2005

China's increased health care spending of $16 billion by the central government in each of the years 2009-2011 is clearly inadequate. Over 200 million are uninsured and the health care system jacks up the costs so much with expensive tests and pills that the poor tend to shun hospitals. The current plan puts off government financed health coverage for 90% of the population till 2020.

Grouped Articles

Bayonne Medical Center Has Highest U.S. Billing Rates

New York Times 05/16/2013

China Sees Challenge On Health System

Wall Street Journal 09/24/2010

Chinese debt: The great hole of China

Economist 10/17/2014

Will patients be rewarded?

Economist 04/16/2009

Free for now

Economist 04/16/2009

A Tiny Tax Could Do a World of Good

New York Times 09/24/2009

China's jobs situation, unemployment, stimulus and growth strategies in 2012-2015

06/04/2012

The excess demand for labor in China in 2012 compared to the excess supply of labor during the global financial crisis of 2008-2009. This has implications for stimulus spending plans, with the measured and selective response in 2012. Another factor is inflation with a 20% rise in wages in the manufacturing sector in 2011, according to the China statistics bureau, so that a large stimulus risks losing the benefits onf anti-inflationary steps taken in 2011-2012. High growth was intended to keep social stability, with excess demand for labor in 2012 this is less of a priority.

Grouped Articles

Strains Show in China's Job Market

Wall Street Journal 06/11/2013

U.S. Stocks Shrug at China's Woes

Wall Street Journal 07/10/2013

I.M.F. Tells China of Urgent Need for Economic Change

New York Times 07/17/2013

Taking Aim at Chinese Jobs

Wall Street Journal 03/05/2014

In China, Beijing Fights Losing Battle to Rein In Factory Production

Wall Street Journal 07/16/2014

Chinese Steel Expert- N Way Out for Mills Caught in Crackdown

Wall Street Journal 07/16/2014

The extraordinary shift in wealth controlled by 10% of the households in China from 31% in 1995 to 86% in 2011, which makes a shift to consumer spending and rebalancing the world economy less likely

10/03/2012

By comparison estimates show 10% of the households in the U.S. control 74% of the wealth. Most of the shift in wealth happened in the last 10 years 2002-2011, as by 2002 41% of the wealth in China was controlled by 10% of households. About 55% of China's households had little or no savings for the year, in this 2011 survey cited by NYT's Orlik, which means a shift to consumer spending for the Chinese economy is less probable in the short run.

Grouped Articles

Rebalancing a Divided China

Wall Street Journal 10/03/2012

Chinese debt: The great hole of China

Economist 10/17/2014

Adidos and Hotwind? In China, Brands Evoke Foreign Names, Even if They’re Gibberish

New York Times 12/26/2014

Apple Warning: Seven Charts That Show the Pressure on China’s Consumers

WSJ 01/03/2019

Chinese Consumers Curb Spending, Likely Deepening Slowdown

WSJ 01/03/2019

Martin Feldstein on China's efforts to control inflation, rising real estate prices, and shift its economy away from export led growth in 2011-2013

01/06/2010

Feldstein says China has the economic problems of inflation, the effects of the large stimulus after the 2008 global financial crisis, and overdependence on exports, under control. The new five year plan gradually shifts the economy towards greater reliance on services and a shift away from export led growth. The smaller stimulus of 2012 is being guided to necessary infrastructure such as power development and towards low income housing. China has still to tackle problems with an aging population and its one-child policy, inequality and corruption in government. These will be challenges facing the new government.

Grouped Articles

Global property markets: Boom and gloom

Economist 05/27/2013

Will China Break?

New York Times 12/18/2011

Zoellick: Chance for Yuan

Wall Street Journal 03/29/2010

China Inflation Rises to a 19-Month High

New York Times 06/11/2010

Compelling Signs the Chinese Property Boom Is Over

Wall Street Journal 03/19/2014

Chinese debt: The great hole of China

Economist 10/17/2014

Coal stockpiles in key storage areas and electricity production data from provinces show steeper decline in China's growth in 2012

06/22/2012

Problems with data on electricity production from the provinces with local officials misrepresenting the true picture. Electricity production and consumption provides a guage for economic activity levels in China because of poor statistical data.

Grouped Articles

Factory Activity Contracts

Wall Street Journal 05/23/2013

How China Fudges Its Numbers

Wall Street Journal 06/19/2013

Chinese debt: The great hole of China

Economist 10/17/2014

For All Its Heft, China’s Economy Is a Black Box

Wall Street Journal 08/25/2015

Chinese Data Said to Be Manipulated, Understating Slowdown

New York Times 06/22/2012

China Digs Into Its Pro-Growth Toolbox

Wall Street Journal 07/12/2012

China's declining GDP growth in 2012-2015

07/13/2012

Grouped Articles

Economists Trim China Growth Forecasts

Wall Street Journal 05/14/2013

China's 'Shadow Banks' Fan Debt-Bubble Fears

Wall Street Journal 06/24/2013

China's Silver Linings Playbook

Wall Street Journal 06/24/2013

China's Credit Crunch

Wall Street Journal 06/25/2013

U.S. Stocks Shrug at China's Woes

Wall Street Journal 07/10/2013

China Forecasts 7.6% Economic Growth in 2013

Wall Street Journal 12/27/2013

Friedman on China and sustainable growth with multiple indicators including education, health care and the environment

01/22/2009

Grouped Articles

Pollution Is Radically Changing Childhood in China’s Cities

New York Times 04/22/2013

China Seeks to Calm Anxiety Over Rice

Wall Street Journal 05/22/2013

China's Credit Crunch

Wall Street Journal 06/25/2013

‘An Uncertain Glory,’ by Jean Drèze and Amartya Sen

New York Times 09/06/2013

Peterson and Hanushek: The Vital Link of Education and Prosperity

Wall Street Journal 09/11/2013

The Shanghai Secret

New York Times 10/22/2013

The IMF and the year to year growth of a country's outstanding Credit to GDP Ratio as a Warning Light Indicator for Country Economies

04/14/2010

The outstanding credit of a country to its GDP ratio and its year to year growth is a warning light indicator is used by the IMF. If the year to year growth in this ratio is over 5 percentage points for a country in a particular year it indicates a warning light. Using this indicator Brazil, China, Turkey are in anticipatory crisis conditions. Use of this indicator would have predicted the crisis in the U.S. in 2008, and the crisis in Ireland, Portugal and Greece, ahead of time so that action could be taken.

Grouped Articles

Asia Goes on a Debt Binge as Much of World Sobers Up

Wall Street Journal 05/24/2013

No Ticker Tape Parade for Brazil's Currency Heroes

Wall Street Journal 06/06/2013

Financial Fears Gain Credence as Unrest Shakes Turkey

New York Times 06/05/2013

China's 'Shadow Banks' Fan Debt-Bubble Fears

Wall Street Journal 06/24/2013

China's Silver Linings Playbook

Wall Street Journal 06/24/2013

China's Credit Crunch

Wall Street Journal 06/25/2013

Rapid acceleration in credit growth in China after 2008 and the complacency about the risks to the financial system

04/14/2010

Grouped Articles

Asia Goes on a Debt Binge as Much of World Sobers Up

Wall Street Journal 05/24/2013

A Warning Light to Alert the I.M.F.

New York Times 09/21/2011

I.M.F. Tells China of Urgent Need for Economic Change

New York Times 07/17/2013

Can China Cool Its Economy?

BusinessWeek 04/14/2010

Chinese Bank Regulator Warns of Loan Risks

Wall Street Journal 06/17/2010

Xi Faces Test Over China's Local Debt

Wall Street Journal 12/31/2013

Off-balance sheet shadow lending by Chinese banks.

01/12/2010

Even after the efforts to restrain lending in 2010 in China following heightened stimulus lending in 2009, the level of bank lending has exceeded 10.5 trillion yuan and is at the same level as 2009. This includes the lending through trusts and other mechanisms according to Fitch Ratings. This explains the inflationary pressures and property bubble.

Grouped Articles

Asia Goes on a Debt Binge as Much of World Sobers Up

Wall Street Journal 05/24/2013

China's 'Shadow Banks' Fan Debt-Bubble Fears

Wall Street Journal 06/24/2013

China's Silver Linings Playbook

Wall Street Journal 06/24/2013

China's Credit Crunch

Wall Street Journal 06/25/2013

China Central Bank Warns Banks on Liquidity

Wall Street Journal 06/25/2013

Credit Warnings Offer World a Peek Into China’s Secretive Banks

New York Times 06/24/2013

Problems facing the China Bank Regulatory Authority (CBRC) for off-balance sheet lending and shadow banks

06/17/2010

Grouped Articles

China's 'Shadow Banks' Fan Debt-Bubble Fears

Wall Street Journal 06/24/2013

China's Silver Linings Playbook

Wall Street Journal 06/24/2013

China's Credit Crunch

Wall Street Journal 06/25/2013

China Central Bank Warns Banks on Liquidity

Wall Street Journal 06/25/2013

Credit Warnings Offer World a Peek Into China’s Secretive Banks

New York Times 06/24/2013

Distress Signs Test Beijing's Resolve

Wall Street Journal 06/25/2013


Support LyrArc

We took a different way to help millions around the world build educated informed mindsets that affects and shapes their lives. For a future that is open, global and digital, with everyone having access to high quality information. We believe in the renewal of America, renewal of Europe, the renewal of India, the rest of Asia, Latin America and Africa. The renewal of our supply chains, health, education, infrastructure, as we rebuild our countries after the pandemic. Literacy and knowledge we believe cannot thrive and grow in a world of web bots, web crawlers, or AI. This requires human curiosity, human learning, and human imagination. We take as inspiration the saying- “One has to be free, and as broad as sky. One has to have a mind that is crystal clear, only then can truth shine in it.” Every contribution whether big or small is precious- in this crisis and ahead.

Support Lyrarc from as small as $1


Copyright © 2006 - 2026 Intelilinks LLC
Terms and Conditions | Copyright Policy | Privacy Policy | Contact Us