World News Insights
1-3 Minute Gist

All Topics Article

How National Belt-Tightening Goes Awry - Economic View

New York Times Original article ›

Keywords:

LyrArc Article Gist
Shiller says policy is captured and communicated by metaphors, the most effective being belt tightening for a family. However what works for a family does not work for a country in the same way, especially if not accompanied by other measures and implemented in a strict manner without looking at the real situation. Better suggests Shiller, and more real is the metaphor of "winter on the family farm," where people work to do other chores than planting and harvesting, because a lot of other things need to be done and this is a good time to do it. This would include cleaning up the place, fixing the farm and the barn, fixing machinery, building fences. The farm's members pay a tax in terms of donated labor which goes to do all the work needed and helps the farm's productiveness as the weather changes. Similiarly the Salant-Paul Samuelson balanced budget theorem from the FDR days shows an increase in national output by the amount of a tax, such as the one proposed in France by president Hollande; that would then be invested in hiring more teachers (the labor) and investing in education infrastructure.

Robert Shiller and "winter on the family farm" as a metaphor in tough economic times instead of "tightening the family belt"

01/27/2009

Shiller cites the "balanced budget theorem" of Salant and the economist Paul Samuelson during the FDR period. This showed that with taxes and expenditures going up during tough economic times the higher output leads to national income increasing by the amount of the tax. French president Hollande's plan to hire 60,000 teachers is of this kind, says shiller, because the higher taxes on incomes over 1 million euros supporting the hiring would increase national income by that amount.

Grouped Articles

The Emperor Creates No Jobs

Wall Street Journal 05/29/2013

Fear of a Double Dip Could Cause One

New York Times 05/14/2010

Robert Shiller: A Skeptic and a Nobel Winner

New York Times 10/19/2013

How to Fix the Economy: An Expert Panel

BusinessWeek 09/16/2010

France's Hollande Replaces Prime Minister Ayrault with Manuel Valls

Wall Street Journal 04/01/2014

How National Belt-Tightening Goes Awry - Economic View

New York Times 05/19/2012

Sarkozy and Hollande economic policy measures and France's economy 2012-2014

04/17/2012

Grouped Articles

France Goes Against the Euro-Zone Flow

Wall Street Journal 04/18/2013

The Emperor Creates No Jobs

Wall Street Journal 05/29/2013

A Proud Nation Ponders How to Halt Its Slow Decline

New York Times 08/24/2013

France Says It Will Miss Budget Deficit Targets

Wall Street Journal 09/12/2013

German Optimism Depends On Spanish Deficits

Wall Street Journal 09/25/2013

French Cabinet Is Dissolved, a Victim of Austerity Battles

New York Times 08/25/2014

The new administration of Francois Hollande in France

05/05/2012

Finance Minister Pierre Muscovici, was European Affairs minister in 1997-2002, Foreign Minister is Laurent Fabius, a former prime minister in the 1980's, and Michel Sapin is Minister for Employment, Labor and Social Dialogue. This gives Hollande an experienced team to implement his program and achieve a reorientation of EU policies towards growth.

Grouped Articles

Year Into Hollande Presidency, ‘a Sense of Drift’

New York Times 05/04/2013

A Proud Nation Ponders How to Halt Its Slow Decline

New York Times 08/24/2013

For France, U.S. delay on Syria fuels doubts - The Washington Post

Washington Post 09/07/2013

France Tries to Tempt In More Foreign Investment

New York Times 02/17/2014

In Race to French Presidency, Hollande Sets His Own Pace

New York Times 05/05/2012

France's Hollande Replaces Prime Minister Ayrault with Manuel Valls

Wall Street Journal 04/01/2014

Italy, Spain and austerity measures- 2011-2013

08/08/2011

Analysts point to the austerity measures adopted by Italy and Spain much earlier than other countries in the eurozone. The risk now is cutting into muscle as growth for 2011 is expected to be below 1% in both countries. Italy say analysts is actually in surplus when the interest on debt is excluded.

Grouped Articles

Italy Urged to Resist a Relapse in Spending

Wall Street Journal 05/03/2013

Still Sputtering, Spain Turns Away From Cuts

Wall Street Journal 05/12/2013

German Election Overturns Political Order

Wall Street Journal 09/23/2013

Those Depressing Germans

New York Times 11/03/2013

Saying No to Austerity, Spain Unveils Tax Cuts

New York Times 06/20/2014

European Finance Ministers Support Investment Program

New York Times 09/14/2014

Italy's 2013 budget and deficits

05/14/2010

The impact on economic growth of austerity measures.

Grouped Articles

Italy Urged to Resist a Relapse in Spending

Wall Street Journal 05/03/2013

Europe to Vote on Tougher Rules for Currency

New York Times 09/27/2011

Italy's debt fuels worries

Wall Street Journal 05/14/2010

Euro Zone Deficit Hits Target for First Time Since 2008

New York Times 04/23/2014

EU Won’t Reject French, Italian Budgets

Wall Street Journal 10/28/2014

European Union Blinks in Budget Battle With Italy and France

New York Times 10/28/2014

The twin problems of lack of growth under austerity plans and overvalued currencies of Italy, Greece, Spain and Portugal

06/24/2011

The twin problems of lack of growth and overvalued currencies under the solutions of austerity plans without debt reduction and a single euro currency create impossible odds for a resolution of the eurozone financial crisis. Germany's insistence on tough austerity measures, European banks delaying restructuring of bad loans similar to the U.S. Brady plan, failure of politicians in Italy and Greece to take early action, and small steps by policymakers, are compounding the effects of the eurozone crisis.

Grouped Articles

German Election Overturns Political Order

Wall Street Journal 09/23/2013

Those Depressing Germans

New York Times 11/03/2013

Germany's Surplus Isn't the Problem

Wall Street Journal 11/11/2013

The 'Silent Austerity' in Banking

Wall Street Journal 01/21/2014

Italy Central Banker Is Open to 'Bad Bank'

Wall Street Journal 02/10/2014

Saying No to Austerity, Spain Unveils Tax Cuts

New York Times 06/20/2014

The 2010 austerity budget and the European financial crisis affecting Spain.

05/13/2010

The contagion effect affecting Spain after Greece and Portugal similar to the manner in which the Asian financial crisis spread during a prior decade.

Grouped Articles

New Spanish Budget Free of Austerity Measures

New York Times 09/27/2013

Saying No to Austerity, Spain Unveils Tax Cuts

New York Times 06/20/2014

Spain is simply shifting the problem

Wall Street Journal 05/14/2010

Amid Europe's challenges, citizens face lifestyle shifts

Wall Street Journal 05/14/2010

French Cracks Are Showing in Euro-Zone Core

Wall Street Journal 05/13/2010

The IMF's Big Wager On Europe

Wall Street Journal 05/13/2010

The IMF comes out on Spain's side in 2012 saying deficit reduction should have taken into account the weaker economic outlook

09/27/2011

The IMF in April 2012 says cuts in Spain may be too severe and cautioned that austerity measures could push Europe into recession.

Grouped Articles

Still Sputtering, Spain Turns Away From Cuts

Wall Street Journal 05/12/2013

Europe to Vote on Tougher Rules for Currency

New York Times 09/27/2011

German Optimism Depends On Spanish Deficits

Wall Street Journal 09/25/2013

The 'Silent Austerity' in Banking

Wall Street Journal 01/21/2014

Euro Zone Deficit Hits Target for First Time Since 2008

New York Times 04/23/2014

Saying No to Austerity, Spain Unveils Tax Cuts

New York Times 06/20/2014

Poverty and hardship in Ireland after austerity measures by the government in 2010

01/04/2009

Grouped Articles

The New Generation Leaving Ireland

BusinessWeek 02/11/2010

Ireland Faces Seventh Year of Austerity

Wall Street Journal 10/16/2013

The Orphans of Ireland

New York Times 04/03/2009

Ireland Faces Battle Over Europe Stability Treaty

New York Times 05/01/2012

Irish Cutbacks Pile It on for 'New Poor'

Wall Street Journal 11/27/2010

Ireland's new government: Enda the party

Economist 03/05/2011

Krugman and other experts on the decision of the government of Ireland to guarantee all the debt of its runaway banks.

08/31/2010

This decision has burdened the Irish people with the debt that banks incurred in a burst of speculative frenzy in real estate. This was possible as bankers were working together with politicians and developers. German and British banks made poor lending decisions and loaned money freely to Irish banks. Banks should share in these losses but the decision of the Irish government has put the burden on the people of Ireland, with a third year of severe austerity cuts in the face of a 14% unemployment rate. The investigation into Anglo Irish Bank.

Grouped Articles

In Ireland, Hope of Retroactive Relief

Wall Street Journal 06/29/2012

Support of Anglo Irish Bank Strains Ireland

New York Times 08/31/2010

Eating the Irish

New York Times 11/25/2010

The Road to Economic Crisis Is Paved With Euros

New York Times 01/12/2011

Europe Needs to Apportion Pain

Wall Street Journal 03/17/2011

Tests Show Irish Banks Still Ailing

New York Times 03/30/2011

Strikes and labor protest in Britain over austerity measures 2011-2012

08/14/2010

Grouped Articles

U.K.'s Labour Party Moves Back Toward Socialist Ideas

Wall Street Journal 09/25/2013

U.K. Politicians Vie to Address Fall in Living Standards

Wall Street Journal 11/18/2013

Radical Britain: The unlikely revolutionary

Economist 08/14/2010

Universities in Britain Brace for Cuts in Subsidies

New York Times 10/15/2010

Britain Details Radical Spending Cuts, Citing Debt

New York Times 10/20/2010

British Fashion Victims

New York Times 10/21/2010

The IMF's changing views on the value of austerity measures and the "German hypothesis"

04/05/2009

The IMF's economic models suggest that it would take 5 years for the breakeven point at which the economic benefits of austerity measures start exceeding the costs of the measures in declining GDP and higher unemployment. The German view is that this can occur in the short term.

Grouped Articles

Policy ‘Troika’ for Europe Financial Woes at Odds

New York Times 06/07/2013

German Election Overturns Political Order

Wall Street Journal 09/23/2013

Known for Tight Spending, I.M.F. May Have to Loosen Reins After G-20 Windfall

New York Times 04/05/2009

Germany Considers Remedies for Slowing Growth

Wall Street Journal 10/08/2014

Merkel Hints at Economic Policy Shift in Germany

New York Times 10/09/2014

How Righteousness Killed the World Economy

New York Times 10/12/2014


Support LyrArc

We took a different way to help millions around the world build educated informed mindsets that affects and shapes their lives. For a future that is open, global and digital, with everyone having access to high quality information. We believe in the renewal of America, renewal of Europe, the renewal of India, the rest of Asia, Latin America and Africa. The renewal of our supply chains, health, education, infrastructure, as we rebuild our countries after the pandemic. Literacy and knowledge we believe cannot thrive and grow in a world of web bots, web crawlers, or AI. This requires human curiosity, human learning, and human imagination. We take as inspiration the saying- “One has to be free, and as broad as sky. One has to have a mind that is crystal clear, only then can truth shine in it.” Every contribution whether big or small is precious- in this crisis and ahead.

Support Lyrarc from as small as $1


Copyright © 2006 - 2026 Intelilinks LLC
Terms and Conditions | Copyright Policy | Privacy Policy | Contact Us