World News Insights
1-3 Minute Gist

All Topics Article

Book review: ‘The Unquiet American: Richard Holbrooke in the World’ - The Washington Post

Washington Post Original article ›

Keywords:

LyrArc Article Gist
Michael Getler describes the missed opportunity under President Obama for using one of America's most talented diplomats to engineer a peace agreement between the warring factions in Afghanistan- the U.S., the Pakistan army, the ISI and its support in the army, the Taliban, and the other parties such as the Haqqani faction and the Afghan government of Karzai. Holbrooke had used his experience for another President, with the same force of his larger than life personality, when he helped bring about the Dayton Accords in a similiar area of stubborn ethnic strife. Could Obama have tapped Holbrooke's skills and set aside the distractions of his personality as coming from an American with unique gifts, talent and achievement, is the question Getler asks. And is this a comment on the nature of the Obama Presidency and America's poorly invested hopes.

Calls for a complete U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan by 2012

02/05/2011

Grouped Articles

U.S. Military Eyes Afghan Force of 10,000, or a Pullout

New York Times 01/21/2014

U.S. Will Complete Afghan Pullout by End of 2016, Obama Says

New York Times 05/27/2014

Obama Details Plan for Forces in Afghanistan

Wall Street Journal 05/28/2014

Amid Drawdown, Fears of Taliban Resurgence and Economic Collapse

New York Times 05/28/2014

U.S. and British Troops End Operations in Key Afghan Province

New York Times 10/26/2014

Let’s Not Linger in Afghanistan

New York Times 07/04/2011

Pakistan's view on the debate in Washington about sending more troops and expansion of war in Afghanistan.

10/01/2009

Foreign Minister Qureshi at the Journal's offices in New York says it would mean the Pakistani Taliban would threaten Islamabad, there would be more misery, suicide bombings, and hurt the economy badly. But Qureshi speaks for an increasingly unpopular Zardari administration. The army, opposition parties, and the Intelligence agencies, and increasingly the public sentiment is against an expanded American presence in Afghanistan, or a bigger American footprint in Afghinstan and Pakistan. See Rosenberg in WSJ.

Grouped Articles

How the Pakistani Taliban Became a Deadly Force

New York Times 12/16/2014

U.S. Credibility and Pakistan

Wall Street Journal 10/01/2009

Several Afghan Strategies, None a Clear Choice

New York Times 10/01/2009

Reconciliation Efforts in Afghanistan Flounder

Washington Post 10/14/2009

Pakistan Attacks Show Tightening of Militant Links

New York Times 10/16/2009

U.S. deeply split on troop increase for Afghan war

Washington Post 10/21/2009

The Pakistan Army and the U.S.

01/07/2008

The increasingly difficult position of General Kayani as he loses support from the rank and file in the army and junior officers on the issue of cooperation with the U.S. Admiral Mullen's criticism of Pakistan after the attacks on the U.S. Embassy in Kabul with the help of Pakistan's intelligence agency ISI.

Grouped Articles

Pakistan Vote to Test Army's Willingness to Cede Power

Wall Street Journal 05/09/2013

Ex-Envoy Says Misunderstanding Runs on Both Sides of U.S.-Pakistan Ties

New York Times 10/22/2013

Visiting Pakistan, Hagel Seeks to Shore Up Alliance

New York Times 12/09/2013

Pakistani forces kill alleged organizer of school massacre - The Washington Post

Washington Post 12/27/2014

Hamid Gul, 78, Dies; Backed Militants in Leading Pakistan Spy Agency

New York Times 08/16/2015

General Kayani Is Said to Cling to Job in Pakistan

New York Times 06/15/2011

A crucial test of leadership of President Obama for the war in Afghanistan and Pakistan- 2009-2010

09/23/2009

Obama has to look at the unofficial reports on the ground to get the facts, and be willing to change completely with the facts, if he is to accept Vice President Biden's view and advisor Reidel's view that counterinsurgency fight is not possible without a credible and legitimate Afghan partner.

Grouped Articles

Pakistan Gives Sharif a Mandate

Wall Street Journal 05/12/2013

Pakistan's New Top Diplomat Heads to Kabul

Wall Street Journal 07/19/2013

Gates Faults Obama Over Afghanistan

Wall Street Journal 01/08/2014

Obama Is Considering Strategy Shift in Afghan War

New York Times 09/23/2009

In Poll, Public Wary of Obama on War and Health

New York Times 09/25/2009

The Afghan Imperative

New York Times 09/25/2009

Prof. Pape shows the escalation of bombings targeting western troops after Afghanistan troop level escalation in years since 2005.

10/15/2009

Prof. Pape of the University of Chicago points to the link between the escalation of bombings targeted at western forces as foreign occupiers and the increase in troops after 2005. About 100,000 foreign troops are on Afghan soil. A military presence without boots on the ground of this magnitude to be seen as foreign occupiers is needed as that will fail in Afghnistan, Pape says.

Grouped Articles

To Beat the Taliban, Fight From Afar

New York Times 10/15/2009

‘You Have Atomic Bombs, but We Have Suicide Bombers.’

New York Times 10/20/2009

More Troops Are a Bad Bet

New York Times 10/22/2009

Kerry Calls for Patient Strategy in Afghanistan

New York Times 10/27/2009

Rethinking the Afghanistan War’s What-Ifs

New York Times 07/31/2010

Book review: ‘The Unquiet American: Richard Holbrooke in the World’ - The Washington Post

Washington Post 11/13/2011

Costs of the war in Afghanistan compared to the war in Vietnam

10/17/2010

Grouped Articles

The Wars That America Forgot About

New York Times 10/17/2010

Worse than Vietnam

New York Times 11/24/2010

Lt. Gen. John Kelly, who lost son to war, says U.S. largely unaware of sacrifice

Washington Post 03/02/2011

The $110 Billion Question

New York Times 03/05/2011

Book review: ‘The Unquiet American: Richard Holbrooke in the World’ - The Washington Post

Washington Post 11/13/2011

White House Proposes Cap on Wartime Spending

Wall Street Journal 02/13/2012

Cost of the war in Afghanistan.

11/15/2009

With the new mine resistant carrier and the surveillance equipment it costs $1 million for each soldier for 1 year.

Grouped Articles

The Wars That America Forgot About

New York Times 10/17/2010

High Costs Weigh on Troop Debate for Afghan War

New York Times 11/15/2009

The War: A Trillion Can Be Cheap

New York Times 07/24/2010

Loss of Faith in Afghan Leaders May Hurt Push Against Taliban

New York Times 09/04/2010

Lt. Gen. John Kelly, who lost son to war, says U.S. largely unaware of sacrifice

Washington Post 03/02/2011

The $110 Billion Question

New York Times 03/05/2011

Declining public support in the U.S. for the war in Afghanistan- 2011-2013

08/11/2010

Public opinion polls showing a steep fall in support for the war in 2012, with 69% favoring withdrawal.

Grouped Articles

Grim Voter Mood Turns Grimmer

Wall Street Journal 08/11/2010

U.S. Military Eyes Afghan Force of 10,000, or a Pullout

New York Times 01/21/2014

U.S. Will Complete Afghan Pullout by End of 2016, Obama Says

New York Times 05/27/2014

Obama Details Plan for Forces in Afghanistan

Wall Street Journal 05/28/2014

Amid Drawdown, Fears of Taliban Resurgence and Economic Collapse

New York Times 05/28/2014

U.S. and British Troops End Operations in Key Afghan Province

New York Times 10/26/2014

Consensus report of 16 US Intelligence Agencies on Afghanistan and Pakistan in December 2010

12/14/2010

The links between Afghanistan and Pakistan and the situation along the border makes the effort in Afghanistan difficult.

Grouped Articles

Intelligence Reports Offer Dim View of Afghan War

New York Times 12/14/2010

Afghan Report Exposes a Split Over Pullout Timelines

New York Times 12/16/2010

Afghan Security Deteriorates

Wall Street Journal 12/27/2010

U.S. efforts fail to convince Pakistan's top general to target Taliban

Washington Post 12/31/2010

The $110 Billion Question

New York Times 03/05/2011

New Afghan War Leader Helped Nurture Sunni Awakening in Iraq

Wall Street Journal 04/28/2011

Fresh thinking for U.S. involvement in Iraq, Afghanistan and other countries, and foreign policies to match the 21st century global architecture.

01/05/2009

The single issue engagement with global partners and rivals is from the 20th century. The USA has to work with other large economies who face the same problems we do, whose biggest challenges are similar to ours.

Grouped Articles

U.S. to Send Up to 300 Military Advisers to Iraq

New York Times 06/19/2014

Chuck Hagel - Why Going It Alone No Longer Works

Washington Post 09/03/2009

Setback in Afghanistan: The Right Response Is Not a Retreat.

Washington Post 09/03/2009

Afghanistan’s Other Front

New York Times 09/16/2009

The Afghan Imperative

New York Times 09/25/2009

Reinforcing failure?

Economist 09/24/2009

Filkins describes a crumbling feudal order of maliks left by the British which makes Afghanistan an even more dangerous place for an American project.

09/07/2008

Dexter Filkins points to another factor in Afghanistan. Not only is there a double game- see the link to Playing the Game- where the army, the ISI and many ordinary Muslims in Pakistan are sympathetic to fellow Muslims fighting the Americans, but there is a social change in process. This may be even more dangerous, as the British left a feudal order intact in Pakistan with a wealthy landholding class, In the Pathan or Pashtun countryside it was run through tribal elders called Maliks, in the Punjab the wealthy feudal landholding ran things pretty much the same way as the British did for the last 50 years. Dexter Filkins points to the crumbling of this structure in the Pathan (Pashtun) countryside.

Grouped Articles

Right at the Edge

New York Times 09/07/2008

Afghanistan Army Tries to Attract Southern Pashtuns

New York Times 09/06/2011

Afghan Myths, 10 Years In

New York Times 10/07/2011

A New Pakistan Policy: Containment

New York Times 10/14/2011

Book review: ‘The Unquiet American: Richard Holbrooke in the World’ - The Washington Post

Washington Post 11/13/2011

The Afghan Surge Is Over - By Rajiv Chandrasekaran | Foreign Policy

Unknown 09/26/2012

Lakhdar Brahimi and a negotiated peace effort for Afghanistan in 2011-2012

03/22/2011

Grouped Articles

Pakistan to Release Senior Taliban Leader

Wall Street Journal 09/11/2013

Sharif and Karzai Try to Repair Ties

Wall Street Journal 10/30/2013

Leader of Pakistani Taliban Killed in Drone Strike

Wall Street Journal 11/02/2013

Time for a Negotiated Political Settlement for Afghanistan

New York Times 03/22/2011

New Afghan War Leader Helped Nurture Sunni Awakening in Iraq

Wall Street Journal 04/28/2011

Bin Laden's Death Brings Calls for Afghan Pullout

Wall Street Journal 05/02/2011

Letters to the Editors of the New York Times on the Vietnam experience and Afghanistan.

10/22/2009

An infantry soldier describes his experience in the fighting, and the attitudes of the Vietnamese people he saw, who were indifferent at best. A former deputy national securtiy advisor to President Johnson points to the contradiction handed down by the Kennedys- dont lose and just use a small number of advisors. An AID adviser to the police describes his experience. Most of the letters see huge risks and losses in Afghanistan. The subject prompting these letters is Lt. Col. Sorley's account of the war in his book "The Better War." In aquestion and answer session on C-SPAN Books on October 24, 2009, Sorley- who led atank battalion in the war- said that a war like that in Vietnam or Afghnistan should be fought only if there is public support behind it on both sides of the poilitical spectrum. He also said that American entry into the Vietnam conflict itself is a contentious issue in that he thinks a good argument could be made for and against entry.

Grouped Articles

Fighting a War in Asia, Then and Now

New York Times 10/22/2009

Kerry Calls for Patient Strategy in Afghanistan

New York Times 10/27/2009

Book review: ‘The Unquiet American: Richard Holbrooke in the World’ - The Washington Post

Washington Post 11/13/2011

Richard Haas on Afghanistan, Pakistan, U.S. national security goals, and action needed to redirect resources.

09/03/2009

Haas calls Afghanistan a strategic distraction and calls for the redirection of resources. The $125 billion spent there each year should go to address national security goals in areas that need it badly-, to reduce the deficit finances which weakens the US, the growing threats from N. Korea and Iran's nuclear development, and modernization needs in defense.

Grouped Articles

In Pakistan, Echoes of American Betrayal

New York Times 07/31/2010

A Foreign Policy Flirting With Chaos

Wall Street Journal 04/30/2014

U.S. Exploring Deal to Limit Pakistan’s Nuclear Arsenal

New York Times 10/15/2015

Let's Un-Surge in Afghanistan

Wall Street Journal 12/20/2010

Afghan Security Deteriorates

Wall Street Journal 12/27/2010

U.S. efforts fail to convince Pakistan's top general to target Taliban

Washington Post 12/31/2010

The Eikenberry cables and the war in Afghanistan.

11/28/2009

The language is strong and rejects McChrystal's appraisal that additional troops can make the difference considering the failure of the Karzai government and the poor prospects for the Afghan army.

Grouped Articles

McChrystal article renews attention to split with Biden over Afghanistan

Washington Post 06/23/2010

Weakening, possible firing of McChrystal compounds sense of peril in Afghanistan

Washington Post 06/23/2010

Afghan Crisis Risks Splitting Country

Wall Street Journal 07/09/2014

Afghans Offer Jobs to Taliban Rank and File if They Defect

New York Times 11/28/2009

Afghan Tribe, Vowing to Fight Taliban, to Get U.S. Aid in Return

New York Times 01/28/2010

U.S. Envoy’s Cables Show Worries on Afghan Plans

New York Times 01/26/2010

Setting a new direction for the Arab and Muslim world.

01/06/2008

Obama's Cairo speech set the tone. But realities on the ground such as achieving reconciliation and efforts to work together among all political parties and factions as the US leaves Iraq, is crucial to set a new direction on the ground. Friedman says Iraq, Pakistan and Afghaistan are part of the same war. And he points out what other experts are saying that in Afghanistan what is done there stays there. Baghdad has the potential for setting anew direction for the Muslim world, as it has been a centre of education, culture and influence in the Muslim world, in the manner Cairo has.

Grouped Articles

Agents of Their Own Destiny

Wall Street Journal 09/25/2015

Education vs. Extremism

Wall Street Journal 06/03/2009

Addressing Muslim World, Obama Pushes Mideast Peace

New York Times 06/05/2009

Iran President and Challenger Clash in Debate

New York Times 06/04/2009

President Obama's Cairo Appeal

Washington Post 06/05/2009

Obama’s Speech in Cairo

Wall Street Journal 06/04/2009

The cost of the war in Afghanistan in priorities at home that are neglected.

10/06/2009

What would the $10 billion to $40 billion extra that 40,000 additional troops would cost buy here in the US to meet urgent needs at home. At $10 billion it could send two million disadvantaged children to a solid preschool, and at $40 billion it could, over 10 years, pay for half the cost of health care reform. And that is not counting the estimated $60 billion it takes to maintain the current trrop level.

Grouped Articles

The Wars That America Forgot About

New York Times 10/17/2010

Does Obama Get It?

New York Times 10/06/2009

More Troops Are a Bad Bet

New York Times 10/22/2009

A Word, Mr. President

New York Times 11/10/2009

High Costs Weigh on Troop Debate for Afghan War

New York Times 11/15/2009

The War: A Trillion Can Be Cheap

New York Times 07/24/2010

Reports from frontline soldiers in the war in Afghanistan- 2011-2012

06/27/2011

Grouped Articles

Obama’s Afghanistan plan gets mixed reviews from grunts at Fort Campbell - The Washington Post

Washington Post 06/27/2011

Book review: ‘The Unquiet American: Richard Holbrooke in the World’ - The Washington Post

Washington Post 11/13/2011

Veteran reporter Dexter Filkins of the NYT talks with McChrystal and looks at the war upfront.

09/07/2008

Dexter Wilkins author of "The Forever War," reports what he has found. One of the things he says is that McChrystal has not thought through the implications for his more boots on the ground policy, when the Karzai government is increasingly seen as an illegitimate and unpopular government. McChrystal's background as a Special Forces commander has not prepared him for grasping its implications. The other is the allergy of the Afghan people to foreign boots, and the vast mountainous terrain, total breakdown or lack of infrastructure, and a people tired of the war. The Pashtuns in Pakistan can be added to this picture. The economic development programs in rural areas are faltering. This may make the Iraqi solution of Petraeus unworkable in Afghanistan, something else may be needed.

Grouped Articles

Weakening, possible firing of McChrystal compounds sense of peril in Afghanistan

Washington Post 06/23/2010

Questions for General McChrystal

New York Times 06/01/2009

Stanley McChrystal’s Long War

New York Times 10/18/2009

In Kabul, Little Hope That a Runoff Will Be Fair

New York Times 10/14/2009

Biden No Longer a Lone Voice on Afghanistan

New York Times 10/14/2009

Not Good Enough

New York Times 10/14/2009

The War in Afghanistan as a Forgotten Issue in 2010.

10/17/2010

Grouped Articles

The Wars That America Forgot About

New York Times 10/17/2010

Lt. Gen. John Kelly, who lost son to war, says U.S. largely unaware of sacrifice

Washington Post 03/02/2011

Pakistan Spy Agency’s Help Sought for Afghan Talks

New York Times 10/30/2011

Book review: ‘The Unquiet American: Richard Holbrooke in the World’ - The Washington Post

Washington Post 11/13/2011

Air Force dumped ashes of more troops’ remains in Va. landfill than acknowledged - The Washington Post

Washington Post 12/08/2011

For one war widow, moving on is a marathon - The Washington Post

Washington Post 07/09/2012

The U.S. Dover Air Force Base Mortuary and remains of war dead from Iraq and Afghanistan

11/10/2011

Grouped Articles

Remains of war dead dumped in landfill - The Washington Post

Washington Post 11/10/2011

Book review: ‘The Unquiet American: Richard Holbrooke in the World’ - The Washington Post

Washington Post 11/13/2011

Air Force dumped ashes of more troops’ remains in Va. landfill than acknowledged - The Washington Post

Washington Post 12/08/2011

For Youngest Veterans, the Bleakest of Job Prospects

New York Times 12/17/2011

U.S. Deplores Video of Marines Urinating on Taliban

New York Times 01/12/2012

For one war widow, moving on is a marathon - The Washington Post

Washington Post 07/09/2012

A much diminished Al Quaeda in Afghanistan next to a growing Taliban focussed on local issues.

01/06/2008

This factors into whether it makes sense for the US to commit large forces in Afghanistan with no clear mission as General Powell suggests.

Grouped Articles

Leader of Pakistani Taliban Killed in Drone Strike

Wall Street Journal 11/02/2013

The Invasion of Pakistan

Wall Street Journal 06/10/2014

Around an Invisible Leader, Taliban Power Shifts

New York Times 12/28/2014

Unruly Factions Hurt Taliban’s Bid to Capture Afghan Hearts, and Territory

New York Times 01/02/2015

Taliban Leader Mullah Omar Is Dead, Afghan Spy Agency Says

Wall Street Journal 07/30/2015

Al Qaeda's Diminished Role Stirs Afghan Troop Debate

Wall Street Journal 10/06/2009

Criticism of the Obama administration's hesitant response to the protests in Egypt

01/28/2011

Vice President Biden says "I would not call Mubarak a dictator." President Obama fails to take a clear position in support of democracy, freedom of expression and economic opportunity in Egypt.

Grouped Articles

Military Madness in Cairo

New York Times 08/14/2013

Adrift on the Nile

New York Times 08/25/2013

Rice Offers a More Modest Strategy for Mideast

New York Times 10/26/2013

Leaving U.S. Allies Adrift as Chaos Rises

Wall Street Journal 08/01/2014

How Do You Solve a Problem Like Mubarak

New York Times 01/28/2011

The U.S. needs to break with Mubarak now

Washington Post 01/29/2011

Failure of the Obama administration's policies in Egypt

02/01/2011

The warnings of a group led by former secretary of state, Madeline Albright, after the rigged elections in Egypt in 2010, were ignored by Hillary Clinton and President Obama. Senator McCain also led efforts to have the Obama administration recognize the deepening problems with suppression of democratic processes in Egypt. Throughout the crisis the Obama administration failed to take a clear stand for democratic processes in Egypt.

Grouped Articles

Adrift on the Nile

New York Times 08/25/2013

Rice Offers a More Modest Strategy for Mideast

New York Times 10/26/2013

U.S. Had Year of Warnings Over Egypt

Wall Street Journal 02/16/2011

Obama Ordered Secret Report on Unrest in Arab World

New York Times 02/16/2011

What we’ve learned in Libya - The Washington Post

Washington Post 08/25/2011

Book review: ‘The Unquiet American: Richard Holbrooke in the World’ - The Washington Post

Washington Post 11/13/2011

How the Muslim world sees America, early in the Obama administration.

01/05/2009

Not much has changed, and in Pakistan it has become more unfavorable after Obama speeches in Cairo and Ankara. The Islamic world and the Middle East has not changed much and some experts say the Arabs see Obama as more rhetoric than substance.

Grouped Articles

‘Beyond War,’ by David Rohde

New York Times 05/03/2013

U.S. must suspend aid after Egypt’s coup - The Washington Post

Washington Post 07/05/2013

Rice Offers a More Modest Strategy for Mideast

New York Times 10/26/2013

Fouad Ajami: When the Obama Magic Died

Wall Street Journal 11/15/2013

Leaving U.S. Allies Adrift as Chaos Rises

Wall Street Journal 08/01/2014

The Arabs Have Stopped Applauding Obama

Wall Street Journal 11/29/2009

Obama and a Rorschach test presidency.

01/18/2009

The tendency of Obama as Presidential candidate to have all kinds of people project their hopes on him was how this Rorschach test phenomenon worked. This does not work well in the Oval Office. As one columnist puts it, in the President's office people tend to project their fears on Obama instead.

Grouped Articles

Fouad Ajami: When the Obama Magic Died

Wall Street Journal 11/15/2013

On the Daily Show, Obama is the last laugh

Washington Post 10/27/2010

Obama’s State of the Union Lays Out Optimistic Tone

Wall Street Journal 01/13/2016

All the President's Captors

New York Times 12/04/2010

Katrina vanden Heuvel - Obama: On the way to a failed presidency?

Washington Post 12/07/2010

Tax-cut deal has liberal Democrats fuming

Washington Post 12/07/2010


Support LyrArc

We took a different way to help millions around the world build educated informed mindsets that affects and shapes their lives. For a future that is open, global and digital, with everyone having access to high quality information. We believe in the renewal of America, renewal of Europe, the renewal of India, the rest of Asia, Latin America and Africa. The renewal of our supply chains, health, education, infrastructure, as we rebuild our countries after the pandemic. Literacy and knowledge we believe cannot thrive and grow in a world of web bots, web crawlers, or AI. This requires human curiosity, human learning, and human imagination. We take as inspiration the saying- “One has to be free, and as broad as sky. One has to have a mind that is crystal clear, only then can truth shine in it.” Every contribution whether big or small is precious- in this crisis and ahead.

Support Lyrarc from as small as $1


Copyright © 2006 - 2026 Intelilinks LLC
Terms and Conditions | Copyright Policy | Privacy Policy | Contact Us