World News Insights
1-3 Minute Gist

All Topics Article

Opinion | Corporate America Is Suppressing Wages for Many Workers

The New York Times Original article ›
LyrArc Article Gist
Krueger and Posner, eminent economists, say the reason wages have stagnated in the U.S. with wages not having budged much over a decade 2008-2018, is not only because of globalization and automation as long term trends. They attribute this stagnation in wages to "monopsony power," or power American corporations have over workers because of their stronger bargaining position and because workers have few alternatives. 

For most of this period 2008-2018 high unemployment as reflected by the people out of work and taking part time jobs or having stopped looking for work, shifted bargaining power to companies. The Economist magazine pointed out that workers have not shared in the profit and gains corporations made during this period.

Here Krueger and Posner show additional factors such as non compete clauses in worker agreements that have depressed wages. Half of franchise agreements prohibit competition for labor. Outsourcing work to other companies that hire workers means these outsourcing companies have more power over workers than the original companies using the labor.

Unions represent only 7 percent of private sector workers by 2017, compared to 35 percent in the 1950's, so that there are no mechanisms to counteract the greater bargaining power gained by companies vs. workers. The way workers have roots in the communities they live and the consolidation of employers into a few companies in a particular area, mean fewer options exist for workers. 

Senators Warren and Booker and the anti-trust division of the U.S. Justice Department are in agreement on this issue of widespread use of noncompete agreements that is considered unlawful, says this report in the NYT, offering hope for a solution to bring a better balance between the rights of workers to fair wages and companies seeking profit for stakeholders.

Issues about workers, lack of gains for workers, prevalent outsourcing, and the frustrations of labor with parties that had lost touch with their worker base- such as Labor in Britain, SPD in Germany, Socialist Party in France and the Democratic Party in the U.S. - have led to political upsets with support shifting to other parties. This has not led to significant change to improve bargaining power of workers to correct the imbalance that now exists between labor and companies, leading to calls for change.

Eric Posner is a law professor at the University of Chicago law school and co-author of a new book "Radical Markets: uprooting Capitalism and Democracy for a Just Society." This book turns the popular notion on its head that free markets have produced the imbalances that hurt social cohesion and democracy, by saying it is precisely the suppression of free competition such as for labor that have created this unhealthy situation. This is true in other areas where monopoly power has developed in other parts of the U.S and European economies in 2008-2018, as also for distortions in capital allocation that hurt infrastructure and other public investment. Krueger is a professor of public affairs at Princeton University and former head of the President's Council of Economic Advisors in 2011 under Obama, showing that Democrats themselves failed to correct this imbalance leading to a shift to other parties and Mr. Trump, who also appear to lack ideas or solutions to this problem that affects social cohesion and democracy. This is contrary to the vision of American or European society of better opportunity for all shared by all Americans and Europeans for most of the twentieth century.


Corporate America and stagnant wage growth 2008-2018

02/28/2018

Grouped Articles

Opinion | Corporate America Is Suppressing Wages for Many Workers

The New York Times 02/28/2018

Trump’s Tax Cuts in Hand, Companies Spend More on Themselves Than on Wages

The New York Times 02/26/2018

Boom in Share Buybacks Renews Question of Who Wins From Tax Cuts

WSJ 03/01/2018

Wages, benefits and productivity in U.S. manufacturing 2005-2015

01/01/2010

Grouped Articles

Does America Need Manufacturing?

New York Times 08/24/2011

Whirlpool Shifts Some Production to U.S. From Mexico

Wall Street Journal 12/20/2013

Americans Sour on Trade

Wall Street Journal 10/02/2010

In U.S., a Cheaper Labor Pool

Wall Street Journal 01/06/2012

U.S. Productivity Growth Has Taken a Dive

Wall Street Journal 02/04/2014

Falling Wages at Factories Squeeze the Middle Class

New York Times 11/20/2014

The other roots of increasing inequality in the U.S.- global competition and sourcing, the case of the U.S. auto industry and manufacturing workers

03/24/2015

Auto parts imports into the U.S. from Mexico have increased by 86% since 2008, more than doubled for China. As wages rise in China, India is the next source country for low cost automobile parts from auto industry hubs in Gujarat and Tamilnadu, placing continuous downward pressure on manufacturing wages for the next decade, and the next. Parts imports were $32 billion in 1990, $138 billion in 2014. Workers in manufacturing make as low as $10 an hour today, similar to workers at Wal-Mart. An entire generation of manufacturing workers are now shifted from middle class to lower class from their parents generation to their own, reducing educational mobility in the American system and fewer opportunities for improvement. As more jobs are created in manufacturing than in IT related industries this is a significant hurdle for improving wages and employment in the U.S.

Grouped Articles

U.S. Car-Making Boom? Not for Auto-Industry Workers

Wall Street Journal 03/24/2015

Income Inequality Is Costing the U.S. on Social Issues

New York Times 04/28/2015

Economic-Ladder Concerns Trump Income Gap in Poll

Wall Street Journal 05/05/2015

Sanders, Corbyn and the coming debate inside the Democratic Party - The Washington Post

Washington Post 09/13/2015

U.A.W. Contract With Fiat Chrysler Would Give 2nd-Tier Workers Big Raise

New York Times 09/18/2015

A stunning stat about pay seems impossible but actually is true - The Washington Post

Washington Post 09/22/2015

High unemployment and declining wages in the U.S.: 2010-2012

01/01/2010

Grouped Articles

OECD report cites rising income inequality - The Washington Post

Washington Post 12/06/2011

Low Pay Clouds Job Growth

Wall Street Journal 08/12/2013

No longer the land of opportunity - The Washington Post

Washington Post 01/05/2012

Recovery Has Created Far More Low-Wage Jobs Than Better-Paid Ones

New York Times 04/27/2014

The world economy: Wealth without workers, workers without wealth

Economist 10/06/2014

Falling Wages at Factories Squeeze the Middle Class

New York Times 11/20/2014

Focus on wages, income disparities, rising inequality, and a shrinking middle class in the first Democratic debate, for the U.S. 2016 presidential election

10/14/2015

O'Malley, Sanders and Clinton emphasize this issue in the debate.

Grouped Articles

The CNN Democratic debate transcript, annotated - The Washington Post

Washington Post 10/14/2015

Democrats Say the Economy Stinks

Wall Street Journal 10/15/2015

Clinton, judged winner of debate, holds big national lead over Sanders - The Washington Post

Washington Post 10/20/2015

Not There Yet on Equal Opportunity

Wall Street Journal 10/21/2015

Elizabeth Warren’s claim that the bottom 90 percent got ‘zero percent’ of wage growth after Reagan - The Washington Post

Washington Post 10/23/2015

Paris massacre could alter the 2016 presidential race in this country - The Washington Post

Washington Post 11/15/2015

The puzzle of continuing U.S. job gains in 2014-2015 with tepid wage growth, low productivity, and low economic growth

03/06/2015

Weak business investment, low productivity, slack in the labor market, and more low paying jobs are some of the reasons explaining the puzzle of job gains in 2014-2015 with small wage gains.

Grouped Articles

Sluggish Productivity Hampers Wage Gains

Wall Street Journal 03/07/2015

After a Bounce, Wage Growth Slumps to 0.1%

New York Times 03/06/2015

The New Jobs Report Shows Janet Yellen’s Quandary in a Nutshell

New York Times 03/06/2015

Slowing Job Growth Tests Economy

Wall Street Journal 04/04/2015

U.S. Economic Growth Nearly Stalls Out

Wall Street Journal 04/29/2015

The Mystery of Declining Productivity Growth

Wall Street Journal 05/15/2015

Globalization and manufacturing job losses in the U.S. and Canada 2000-2015

01/26/2016

Wage stagnation in the manufacuring sector in the U.S. is another aspect of the globalization trends, as workers in the U.S. compete with low wage workers in emerging markets such as Mexico and China.

Grouped Articles

What’s Our Duty to the People Globalization Leaves Behind?

New York Times 01/26/2016

After Michigan Loss, Hillary Clinton Sharpens Message on Jobs and Trade

New York Times 03/09/2016

Brexit: The Era of the Angry Voter Is Upon Us - SPIEGEL ONLINE

SPIEGEL ONLINE 07/06/2016

Trump era confronts organized labor with gravest crisis in decades

Washington Post 12/09/2016

The White House’s claim that 800,000 manufacturing jobs were added during Obama’s presidency

Washington Post 12/09/2016

Mexico is growing less pessimistic about Donald Trump

The Economist 04/14/2017

Shift of American manufacturing overseas and the disastrous results for jobs, pandemic

08/27/2020

Grouped Articles

How China Built ‘iPhone City’ With Billions in Perks for Apple’s Partner

The New York Times 12/29/2016

California Nears Deal to Adopt a $15 State Minimum Wage

New York Times 03/27/2016

Opinion | Bringing the Factories Home

WSJ 07/19/2020

Donald Trump Presides Over GOP Remade in His Image

WSJ 08/26/2020

China’s Faux Comparative Advantage

WSJ 04/15/2018

Opinion | Corporate America Is Suppressing Wages for Many Workers

The New York Times 02/28/2018


Support LyrArc

We took a different way to help millions around the world build educated informed mindsets that affects and shapes their lives. For a future that is open, global and digital, with everyone having access to high quality information. We believe in the renewal of America, renewal of Europe, the renewal of India, the rest of Asia, Latin America and Africa. The renewal of our supply chains, health, education, infrastructure, as we rebuild our countries after the pandemic. Literacy and knowledge we believe cannot thrive and grow in a world of web bots, web crawlers, or AI. This requires human curiosity, human learning, and human imagination. We take as inspiration the saying- “One has to be free, and as broad as sky. One has to have a mind that is crystal clear, only then can truth shine in it.” Every contribution whether big or small is precious- in this crisis and ahead.

Support Lyrarc from as small as $1


Copyright © 2006 - 2026 Intelilinks LLC
Terms and Conditions | Copyright Policy | Privacy Policy | Contact Us