World News Insights
1-3 Minute Gist

All Topics Article

Transatlantic Partnership: Europe's Illusions | ZEIT ONLINE

ZEIT ONLINE Original article ›
LyrArc Article Gist
This response by experts on transatlantic relations rejects the other view expressed in Zeit Online that the U.S. under Trump remains estranged from Germany and the EU. These experts from the American Institute for German Contemporary Studies, American German Council, and Centers at John Hopkins and Georgetown for German Studies, reject the view that the Trump administration and Germany are that far apart on many issues as it appears from media coverage. 

Foremost it points out that civil society relations are sound and growing. About 50 million Americans trace their descent to Germany, including president Trump, much larger to over half the U.S. population considering European descent. Much larger is the sense of a culturally shared future with the European Union, with the nations of Europe including Germany, France, Italy, Spain, the nations of Eastern Europe, and Britain. The civil society relationships run deep in a way that is hardly affected by the Trump administration.

Within the Trump administration the policies to Europe these experts remind the reader, are determined by the "adults" in the administration, who are senior members of the administration. This is a crucial point as Trump administration policy is not determined by the president's liking for tweets as much as by senior cabinet members Tillerson at the State Department, Gen. Mattis at Defense, Kelly at the White House, and senior members of Congress including Senators Corker and other senior committee members. This is why Republican Senator Kay Hutchinson was chosen as Ambassador to NATO.

It should be noted in this context of German-EU relations in president Trump's first year that there was a period of German disillusionment with president Obama, exacerbated by the NSA spying on German chancellor Merkel and on the EU delegation to the UN, with president Obama's failure to offer any apology. Relations recovered from that low point. No one suggested that there be a German led decoupling of the EU with America at that low point, or at another low point in German-U.S. relations with the setup of American Pershing II nuclear missiles on German soil under the Reagan administration when there were large scale protests. 

The American view that the U.S. should not have to shoulder major responsibilities for defense and foreign relations by itself is not new say these experts, and goes back to earlier administrations before Trump.  The experts argue for an active role by Germany with its partners in Europe for defense and foreign relations, which should not be seen as a result of U.S. pressure, only responding to the situation as it has evolved upto this time. Views on immigration are also changing with effort by the EU and Germany, France, to reduce immigration from the source countries in Africa, and the changing perceptions about uncontrolled immigration in Germany and France, say the authors.

A coordinated policy towards Russia  is seen as not having changed. And much as a reset in relations was advocated by Obama in the first year of his first term, the current policy of the Trump administration to work with Russia to lower tensions can be seen in the same way say these experts, and not as a fundamental shift in American policy.

The deep relationship of Germany and the EU with China is another positive aspect that will also help the U.S. in framing its own policies towards China.

The German-American relationship, and the European Union relationship with the U.S.  is seen as basic to the values and interests of the U.S. and Europe. This relationship is too deep and supported by civil society and Congress, the Republican Party, and the Democratic Party, by large trade relationships, to be affected by temporary differences under any one administration. Even these differences are part of a larger debate that is part of dialogue on issues in a democratic society, sometimes raucous and loud, and could be welcomed and carefully channelled in constructive ways.

 

 


Trans-Atlantic Trade and Investment Treaty (TTIP) unpopular in Germany

04/24/2016

As U.S. president Obama pushed for the treaty during his visit to the Hannover Fair, German newspapers say the treaty is even more unpopular now than when polls showed that about half of Germans opposed the treaty. Protesters in Hannover say they oppose the treaty because it benefits big business at the expense of working people. Hillary Clinton, Donald Trump and Ted Cruz oppose the trade treaties. Experts say most of the benefits from trade have already been gained, and the priorities have shifted to infrastructure, wages and the working class in the U.S. and in Europe, as some sections of society have lagged behind.

Grouped Articles

Obama Joins Angela Merkel in Pushing Trade Deal to a Wary Germany

New York Times 04/24/2016

More Wealth, More Jobs, but Not for Everyone: What Fuels the Backlash on Trade

The New York Times 09/28/2016

Trump Rhetoric Poses Dangers to American Democracy - SPIEGEL ONLINE

SPIEGEL ONLINE 10/19/2016

EU says new talks on TTIP unlikely after Trump win | Business | DW.COM | 11.11.2016

DW.COM 11/11/2016

Trump era confronts organized labor with gravest crisis in decades

Washington Post 12/09/2016

The White House’s claim that 800,000 manufacturing jobs were added during Obama’s presidency

Washington Post 12/09/2016

Negotiations for a Transatlantic EU-U.S. Trade Agreement 2013-2014

02/14/2013

Further progress in reducing tariffs could increase transatlantic trade by an estimated $120 billion over 5 years from the current figure of $1 trillion, according to the U.S. Chamber of Commerce. U.S. president Obama announced support for negotiations in Feb 2013.

Grouped Articles

NSA Flap Strains Ties With Europe

Wall Street Journal 02/10/2014

Carmakers Are Central Voice in U.S.-Europe Trade Talks

New York Times 07/14/2014

Obama Promotes Benefits of Trade Deals to Workers and Smaller Businesses

New York Times 02/26/2015

Obama Joins Angela Merkel in Pushing Trade Deal to a Wary Germany

New York Times 04/24/2016

Broad Trade Deal on Table

Wall Street Journal 02/14/2013

What the New GOP Means for Wall Street

WSJ 07/19/2016

European Union trade deal with Japan in 2017 countering Trump administration protectionism

07/05/2017

The EU trade deal with Japan in July 2017 is announced about the time of G-20 meetings in Hamburg, Germany. It is intended to be a response to the protectionist tone of the new Trump administration in the U.S.

Grouped Articles

Challenging Trump, E.U. and Japan Push Joint Trade Deal

The New York Times 07/04/2017

Angela Merkel: Her Long Road to Trudering | ZEIT ONLINE

ZEIT ONLINE 06/02/2017

Transatlantic Partnership: Europe's Illusions | ZEIT ONLINE

ZEIT ONLINE 10/31/2017

On a common approach for the U.S. and Germany in the relationship with Russia

04/02/2009

Grouped Articles

In Cold War Echo, Obama Strategy Writes Off Putin

New York Times 04/19/2014

U.S.-Russia Relations Come Full Circle After Ukraine

Wall Street Journal 04/21/2014

Promises of ‘Fresh Start’ for U.S.-Russia Relations

New York Times 04/02/2009

The Russia Problem

Wall Street Journal 04/28/2014

Why Germans Love Russia

New York Times 05/05/2014

Germany's Wolfgang Schäuble: Prepared to Raise Pressure on Russia

Wall Street Journal 05/24/2014

The Alternate View about U.S. and EU relations with Russia from Gates and German opinion

01/05/2009

An alternate view about U.S. and EU relations with Russia from former Defense Secretary Gates and German public opinion which looks at Georgia, Crimea, Ukraine, in the larger context of the postwar years beyond todays headlines.

Grouped Articles

Pentagon Chief Sees Opportunities In Russia and the War on Terrorism

Washington Post 01/05/2009

Twin Shocks Shake Foundation of German Power

New York Times 04/18/2014

In Cold War Echo, Obama Strategy Writes Off Putin

New York Times 04/19/2014

U.S.-Russia Relations Come Full Circle After Ukraine

Wall Street Journal 04/21/2014

Promises of ‘Fresh Start’ for U.S.-Russia Relations

New York Times 04/02/2009

Why Germans Love Russia

New York Times 05/05/2014

U.S. -Germany relations

07/22/2014

Grouped Articles

Obama Sends Aide to Soothe German Allies

New York Times 07/22/2014

Germans at the Crux of Crises, but Reluctantly

New York Times 02/28/2015

A Sheep in Wolf’s Clothes

Wall Street Journal 03/11/2015

Over Beer, Obama and Merkel Mend Ties and Double Down on Russia

New York Times 06/07/2015

Obama’s Trip to Germany Reflects New Closeness

Wall Street Journal 04/23/2016

Germany Reacts to Merkel-Trump Visit: ‘Could Have Been a Lot Worse’

The New York Times 03/18/2017

Rebuilding trust in German- U.S. relations after the NSA spying on German chancellor Merkel

10/31/2013

Grouped Articles

Repairing Trust Among Allies

New York Times 11/01/2013

One Casualty of Eavesdropping on Merkel: A Warm Rapport

New York Times 11/01/2013

Germany’s Blind Spot

New York Times 10/31/2013

Shaken NSA Grapples With an Overhaul

Wall Street Journal 11/25/2013

White House to preserve controversial policy on NSA, Cyber Command leadership - The Washington Post

Washington Post 12/14/2013

U.S. to Stick With Combined NSA, Cyber Command Posts

Wall Street Journal 12/14/2013

Lt. Gen. Frederick "Ben" Hodges, Commander of the U.S. Army in Europe on the threats and challenges facing the U.S. and lack of spare resources for crises

02/09/2015

Lt. Gen. "Ben" Hodges says today 9 out of 10 divisional headquarters are committed, a situation unprecedented even at the height of the U.S. action in Afghanistan and Iraq. New crises are emerging that no one could predict such as Islamic State and Ukraine in 2014. Spare resources to meet new threats are urgently needed but the army is limited by the sequestration budget cuts, sending the wrong type of message to bad actors in the Middle East and Europe, says Hodges. Senators generally think of their state first, Texans about Ft. Hood, Carolinans about Fort Campbell, but no one represents Fort Wiesbaden, Germany. Hodges is based at the U.S. army base in Wiesbaden, Germany.

Grouped Articles

The View From NATO’s Russian Front

Wall Street Journal 02/09/2015

Defense Chief: Subversion, ‘Big Lie’ Are in Russia’s Arsenal

Wall Street Journal 06/06/2015

U.S. Is Poised to Put Heavy Weaponry in Eastern Europe

New York Times 06/13/2015

This Is No Time to Cut The U.S. Army

Wall Street Journal 08/14/2015

U.S. Military Officials Aim to Bolster Troop Presence in Europe

Wall Street Journal 11/10/2015

Notable & Quotable: John McCain on NATO

Wall Street Journal 04/08/2016

Disillusionment with U.S. president Obama in Germany

04/05/2009

Grouped Articles

Germans Loved Obama. Now We Don’t Trust Him.

New York Times 06/29/2013

Spy Claims Send Chill Ahead of Trade Talks

Wall Street Journal 07/02/2013

One Casualty of Eavesdropping on Merkel: A Warm Rapport

New York Times 11/01/2013

Repairing Trust Among Allies

New York Times 11/01/2013

The Lines a German Won’t Cross

New York Times 04/05/2009

Germans at the Crux of Crises, but Reluctantly

New York Times 02/28/2015

The Obama administration and setting up a reciprocal agreement with France and Germany that prohibits spying on each other

04/05/2009

After German and French revelations about NSA spying activities in Germany and France, including spying on German chancellor Merkel's mobile phone, the pressure is increasing for the U.S. to sign a reciprocal agreement on no-spying with the two European partners. The U.S. already has an understanding with three English speaking countries on no-spying and it makes sense for this to apply to critical Eurpean allies.

Grouped Articles

Allegation of U.S. Spying on Merkel Puts Obama at Crossroads

New York Times 10/24/2013

Data Suggests Push to Spy on Merkel Dates to ’02

New York Times 10/27/2013

Spain Summons U.S. Ambassador in Spying Scandal

New York Times 10/28/2013

Obama Unaware as U.S. Spied on World Leaders: Officials

Wall Street Journal 10/28/2013

Would Obama Be OK With German Snoops?

Wall Street Journal 10/28/2013

Europeans Shared Spy Data With U.S.

Wall Street Journal 10/30/2013


Support LyrArc

We took a different way to help millions around the world build educated informed mindsets that affects and shapes their lives. For a future that is open, global and digital, with everyone having access to high quality information. We believe in the renewal of America, renewal of Europe, the renewal of India, the rest of Asia, Latin America and Africa. The renewal of our supply chains, health, education, infrastructure, as we rebuild our countries after the pandemic. Literacy and knowledge we believe cannot thrive and grow in a world of web bots, web crawlers, or AI. This requires human curiosity, human learning, and human imagination. We take as inspiration the saying- “One has to be free, and as broad as sky. One has to have a mind that is crystal clear, only then can truth shine in it.” Every contribution whether big or small is precious- in this crisis and ahead.

Support Lyrarc from as small as $1


Copyright © 2006 - 2026 Intelilinks LLC
Terms and Conditions | Copyright Policy | Privacy Policy | Contact Us