World News Insights
1-3 Minute Gist

All Topics Article

Fareed Zakaria: Let’s be honest, Islam has a problem right now - The Washington Post

Washington Post Original article ›

Keywords:

LyrArc Article Gist
Bernard Lewis's "The Arabs in History," is a short book which confirms Zakaria's point about the openness of Islamic societies before the 19th century, with some exceptions in certain periods. Most books or a quick look at Wikipedia shows us that the Renaissance in Europe in the 15th century got its boost from books by ancient Greek authors that were available in Arab societies long after they were forgotten in Europe. His point about Indonesia and India is also true to a large extent except for periods such as the one under Aurangzeb (17th c.). Muslim societies in British India (todays Pakistan and Bangladesh) experienced less social and educational reforms under the British than Hindu societies for various reasons leading to larger backwardness, illiteracy which breed extremist ideas. This is likely to change throughout North African Arab societies and South Asia in the next 50 years, especially with the modernization drive underway in India, which is likely to spread to other parts of the region. Islam as a missionary religion with force of arms spread in the 7th-9th century rapidly over Arab North Africa and parts of west Asia, and later to South Asia. Once established there were long periods of openness to ideas and books, and different cultures ( with the exception of preferences for Muslims), and a stress on commerce which inherently reduces religious vehemence, as the example of Britain shows. For this reason the current conditions in Islamic societies is more atypical than typical. A factor that has worsened it is that 19th c.-20th c. Islamic societies have put less emphasis on commerce and industry than historically seen in prosperous Islamic societies, on which more research is needed to understand why. Another factor is the impact of the interface with technologically and scientifically progressing Europe and America not becoming a learning experience for acquisition of this science and technology and making it one's own, a pattern seen in Buddhist societies of Japan in 19th c., South Korea in 20thc.,and China 21st c. Because Buddhism sprang from Hinduism or a response to Hindu ideas in India, India could be put alongside China for the 21st c. rapid assimilation of western science and technology making it one's own. When there is a violent collison between Japan and U.S. Admiral Dewey's ships, or China and British advances around 1900, the initial reaction of rejection is reversed with adoption of western technology and practices making it one's own. Similiar response in India. Islamic societies have had an extended period of rejection for reasons not fully understood even today. This is likely to generate the kind of internal debate about how to revert back to the usual mode of adoption in Islamic civilization, with the potential catalyst in India and other locations in the Middle East. The most respected German of the 19th century is Alexander Von Humboldt, a naturalist who advanced scientific knowledge, and a mentor to Charles Darwin in England, author of "Origin of the Species." Humboldt says- "There are no inferior races, we are all humans, and we are all destined to reach for and grasp liberty." That Humboldt spent most of his best years in Paris, France, which he compared to the provincialism in his native Berlin, goes to show how Humboldt, Darwin and Humboldt's friend Aime Bonpland of France, maintained close cooperation and friendship and anticipated the close cooperation in Europe since the second half of the 20th c., long before European politicians and governments grasped this. Commerce, science, travel, media and free exchange of ideas, are as favorable to progress as politics and ideology is inimical to it.

A look back and insights from former U.S. Defense Secretary, Robert Gates, about Russia and Islamic terrorism not being the threats the way they are perceived

01/05/2009

A detailed look at Russia and Islamic terrorism from Gates that provides perspective and insights beyond the daily headlines about Russia (Georgia, then Crimea) and Islamic terrorists (in Iraq and the Middle East). Two critical points made by Gates about Russia- Russia lacks the capabilities it once had, and the demographics in Russia of a declining population which limit its influence. He sees Georgia, (and possibly Crimea) in the light of Russia exorcizing past humiliations something that Putin has repeatedly referred to in his speeches. The perspective also opens up thinking about what to look for in the future including surprises around the corner. By 2014 for example relations between countries in Asia had deteriorated regarding island disputes.

Grouped Articles

Pentagon Chief Sees Opportunities In Russia and the War on Terrorism

Washington Post 01/05/2009

In Cold War Echo, Obama Strategy Writes Off Putin

New York Times 04/19/2014

U.S.-Russia Relations Come Full Circle After Ukraine

Wall Street Journal 04/21/2014

Promises of ‘Fresh Start’ for U.S.-Russia Relations

New York Times 04/02/2009

Former Defense Secretary Gates Is Elected President of the Boy Scouts

New York Times 05/22/2014

This Is Just a Date, Not a Marriage

Wall Street Journal 06/03/2014

Egypt's Al-Azhar mosque and politics in Islamic countries

02/20/2011

Grouped Articles

Morsi’s ouster spells trouble for region’s other Islamist movements - The Washington Post

Washington Post 07/04/2013

Egypt’s Revolution Part II

New York Times 07/04/2013

Egypt's Adly Mansour: Top Judge for Two Days, Now Interim President

Wall Street Journal 07/03/2013

Fouad Ajami: Egypt on the Brink—With No Clear Way Back

Wall Street Journal 07/02/2013

U.S. must suspend aid after Egypt’s coup - The Washington Post

Washington Post 07/05/2013

Why I'm Not Cheering Along With My Fellow Egyptians

Wall Street Journal 07/05/2013

Gomaa, Saleh, El-Haddad and Morsi- anguish, hope and an opportunity to forge a new path for Egypt where the modern world thrives alongside a open tolerant Islam

02/04/2011

An opportunity to set the Arab world and the Middle East in a new direction. The European Renaissance began with one of the important influences being ideas and books brought back from open and tolerant Islamic societies, the opportunity for leaders in the Middle East to borrow in the same way from open and tolerant Christian societies in Europe and America and forge their own path to a modern world and make their own contributions.

Grouped Articles

Morsi blames corruption, conspiracy for Egypt’s problems - The Washington Post

Washington Post 06/27/2013

Morsi Faces Ultimatum as Allies Speak of Military ‘Coup’

New York Times 07/01/2013

Onetime Morsi Supporters Allege Egypt Leader Shifted

Wall Street Journal 07/03/2013

Fouad Ajami: Egypt on the Brink—With No Clear Way Back

Wall Street Journal 07/02/2013

Egypt's Adly Mansour: Top Judge for Two Days, Now Interim President

Wall Street Journal 07/03/2013

Morsi’s ouster spells trouble for region’s other Islamist movements - The Washington Post

Washington Post 07/04/2013

Islam, immigration, multiculturalism and public opinion in Europe

02/21/2011

Grouped Articles

A Neo-Nazi’s Political Rise Exposes a German City’s Ethnic Tensions

New York Times 06/24/2014

Fareed Zakaria: Let’s be honest, Islam has a problem right now - The Washington Post

Washington Post 10/10/2014

Swiss Voters Reject Move to Restrict Immigrants

New York Times 11/30/2014

Proud to Offend, Charlie Hebdo Carries Torch of Political Provocation

New York Times 01/07/2015

‘Dangerous Moment’ for Europe, as Fear and Resentment Grow

New York Times 01/07/2015

France’s Secularist Model Is Challenged by Attack

Wall Street Journal 01/09/2015

Pakistan groping for a new identity after failure of religion in the state.

09/29/2006

The failure of Islam as astate ideology to give Pakistan peace with its neighbors, and to modernize Pakistan. Instead of working it has proved dysfunctional and led to failures in economic development, failure in building ademocratic state, and left the country in abackward state with many divisions along political and tibal lines. The new identity being sought would keep Islam out of politics and set new priorities.

Grouped Articles

Pakistani Judge Gains Clout

Wall Street Journal 04/22/2013

Pakistan Vote to Test Army's Willingness to Cede Power

Wall Street Journal 05/09/2013

Morsi’s ouster spells trouble for region’s other Islamist movements - The Washington Post

Washington Post 07/04/2013

Egypt’s Revolution Part II

New York Times 07/04/2013

Egypt's Adly Mansour: Top Judge for Two Days, Now Interim President

Wall Street Journal 07/03/2013

Fouad Ajami: Egypt on the Brink—With No Clear Way Back

Wall Street Journal 07/02/2013

Saudi Arabia and Salafism -a tolerance for extreme views of Islam in the Saudi state

08/22/2014

Grouped Articles

ISIS Atrocities Started With Saudi Support for Salafi Hate

New York Times 08/22/2014

Fareed Zakaria: Let’s be honest, Islam has a problem right now - The Washington Post

Washington Post 10/10/2014

A Smooth Saudi Succession, but a Rough Road Ahead

Wall Street Journal 01/26/2015

Saudis and Extremism: ‘Both the Arsonists and the Firefighters’

The New York Times 08/25/2016

Sociey and culture in Turkey caught between its Islamic Ottoman heritage and the modern period in the twentieth century

04/07/2009

Grouped Articles

Turkish Airlines CEO to Take Leave

Wall Street Journal 05/14/2013

Identity Shift Giving Rise to 2 Turkeys

New York Times 11/30/2012

Protests Widen in Turkey; Riot Police Pull Back

Wall Street Journal 06/01/2013

Development Won’t Ensure Democracy in Turkey

New York Times 06/05/2013

Turkey’s Middle Class Strikes Back

New York Times 06/05/2013

Turkish Leader Says Razing of Park to Proceed

New York Times 06/06/2013

The insurgency in Iraq in 2014 against the Maliki government's sectarian policies- the Islamic state of Iraq and Syria

06/10/2014

Mosul on the border with Syria is taken by the insurgents ISIS (Islamic State of Iraq and Syria) who operate on the Syrian side against Assad. Mosul is Iraq's second largest city with different ethnic groups. Foreign fighters operating in Syria have joined the ISIS. Maliki had lost support in Mosul with his increasingly sectarian policies favoring Shiites and marginalizing Sunnis. The Iraqi forces lack training and are poorly organized compared to the insurgents fighting the Assad regime in Syria. The U.S. lost any chance of maintaining peace in the region with policies of the Obama administration distancing itself in Iraq, Syria and towards Iran's non-sectarian democracy movement. With moderates left in the cold in the region, sectarian influences are taking control and undoing the hard work of previous administrations. The hopes of the heavily young demographic oriented Middle East region in 2011-2012 for economic progress are now fading first into religious extremism and then into sectarian religious conflict, with Putin's government in Russia allowed by the Obama administration to pursue reckless policies in Syria against the interests of people in the region. A no fly zone or action of the kind taken in Libya at very small cost to the U.S. was not taken by U.S. president Obama. The failed reelection bid of Sarkozy in France left Britain's prime minister Cameron with no allies to pursue prudent policies in Syria that would have advanced democracy and economic development in the entire region.

Grouped Articles

Sunni Militants Drive Iraqi Army Out of Mosul

New York Times 06/10/2014

The Fall of Mosul

Wall Street Journal 06/11/2014

Iraqi, U.S. Forces Trade Barbs Over Failures

Wall Street Journal 06/12/2014

Mosul Falls to ISIS, Endangering Iraq’s Democracy

New York Times 06/11/2014

U.S. Said to Rebuff Iraqi Request to Strike Militants

New York Times 06/11/2014

Sunni Fighters Gain as They Battle 2 Governments, and Other Rebels

New York Times 06/11/2014

The Iranian movement of 50 universities that coalesces around December 7.

12/18/2009

December 7, 1953, was the date that students protests agains t the overthrow of the elected Mossadegh governemt took place and student protests have continued under the Sha's regime and under the Islamic Khamanei regime. The vast majority of young people especially in the urban areas it seems are now against the rigged election regime of the Ahmadinejad government.

Grouped Articles

Prospect of Iran’s Election Stirs Little Hope This Time Around

New York Times 05/08/2013

Iran's Reformists Get Pre-Election Surge

Wall Street Journal 06/14/2013

Rouhani addresses Iran’s divided students - The Washington Post

Washington Post 12/07/2013

Fareed Zakaria: Let’s be honest, Islam has a problem right now - The Washington Post

Washington Post 10/10/2014

Ayatollah Khamenei, Backing Iran Negotiators, Endorses Nuclear Deal

New York Times 07/18/2015

Malaysia’s Missed Democracy Lesson

Wall Street Journal 07/24/2015

The participation of the Islamist and the secular leaders in the new government of Libya

01/05/2009

Islamists say they are misunderstood. They only want freedom to go the mosque and individual freedoms. One Islamist leaders says westerners do not understand them and think they want to lock up their women in boxes. Islamist and Muslim Brotherhood rebels did a lot of the hard fighting against the Gaddafi regime and Belhaj is one of the leaders running the capital Tripoli. See the interview with Belhaj by Rod Nordland in the New York Times, Sept. 1, 2011. Belhaj says he is grateful to NATO and the West for the help in fighting Gaddafi and holds no rancor- even though he was turned over to the Gaddafi regime by the CIA in this amazing account by Nordland.

Grouped Articles

Morsi’s ouster spells trouble for region’s other Islamist movements - The Washington Post

Washington Post 07/04/2013

Jurist Sworn In to Lead Egypt Transition

New York Times 07/04/2013

Egypt’s Revolution Part II

New York Times 07/04/2013

Demoting Democracy in Egypt

New York Times 07/04/2013

Still Torn by Factional Fighting, Post-Revolt Libya Is Coming Undone

New York Times 07/27/2014

U.S., European Allies Raise Alarm About Escalating Violence in Libya

Wall Street Journal 08/26/2014

U.S., Germany, Russia, Brazil and the anti-Islamic video on the Prophet Muhammad in Sept. 2012

09/12/2012

Google's You Tube service provided the access to what would have been an obscure and crude video. This raises several questions- would a crude video of this type on the Buddha or Krishna be given similar access on the basis of the First Amendment and what would be the response in S. Korea, Japan, and India? Would it then be withdrawn. Is an election candidate for local government in Brazil entitled to protection because of Brazil's election laws? This was decided in favor of the election candidate after Brazilian courts ordered the arrest of the head of the Google affiliate in Brazil and Google then reversed its stand and removed it from You Tube. Are there unwritten laws and is the Prophet entitled to the same protection under unwritten laws that govern most of daily human behaviour in America and Europe? Does the First Amendment protect everything that new technology providers such as Google do, or do unwritten laws and good common sense prevail until new laws can be written for use of new technology, if such laws are needed that protect First Amendment rights without infringing on other rights.

Grouped Articles

Fareed Zakaria: Let’s be honest, Islam has a problem right now - The Washington Post

Washington Post 10/10/2014

Proud to Offend, Charlie Hebdo Carries Torch of Political Provocation

New York Times 01/07/2015

‘Dangerous Moment’ for Europe, as Fear and Resentment Grow

New York Times 01/07/2015

Inside the U.S. Antitrust Probe of Google

Wall Street Journal 03/20/2015

Take Google to Court, Staff Report Urged F.T.C.

New York Times 03/19/2015

Germany Weighs Banning Video

Wall Street Journal 09/17/2012

Turkey, the mosque project at Taksim Square, and the struggle between the Islamists and secularists

06/23/2013

Grouped Articles

Mosque Dream Seen at Heart of Turkey Protests

New York Times 06/23/2013

Erdogan Tightens Grip on Turkey, Putting Nation at Crossroads

Wall Street Journal 06/27/2013

Morsi’s ouster spells trouble for region’s other Islamist movements - The Washington Post

Washington Post 07/04/2013

Egypt’s Revolution Part II

New York Times 07/04/2013

U.S. must suspend aid after Egypt’s coup - The Washington Post

Washington Post 07/05/2013

Turkey Court Gives 10 Life Sentences

Wall Street Journal 08/05/2013

The U.S., EU and Islamic terrorism in Iraq and Afghanistan- An Alternate view from Gates for 2014-2016

01/05/2009

Former Defense Secretary Gates offers an alternate view about how Islamic terrorism happened and how it should be seen in a larger context of the post war years.

Grouped Articles

Pentagon Chief Sees Opportunities In Russia and the War on Terrorism

Washington Post 01/05/2009

Fareed Zakaria: Let’s be honest, Islam has a problem right now - The Washington Post

Washington Post 10/10/2014

The U.S. Has No Global Strategy

Wall Street Journal 02/01/2016

Why today's Islamic societies and nations are more anomaly than fitting into the pattern of Islamic commercial societies in history

10/10/2014

Trade and commerce was an essential part of the great Islamic societies in history, giving them a large degree of openness and liberal ideas. This is not always present, but is so to a large extent in long periods of prosperity. For various reasons needing more research, this changed and reverted to less receptiveness to science and technology in the 19th c. and 20th c. , a period when great advances in medicine, industry, transport, were made in Europe and America. Buddhist societies confronted this influence in 19thc and 20th c. with warinness and suspicion, but later changed to open embrace for Japan in 19th c. , S, Korea in 20th c. , China in 21st c. , and India (as Buddhist-Hindu) in 21st c. The potential is for this to change with Indian and Indonesian Muslims acting as a catalyst for Islam swinging back to its usual mode, but can take a few decades to develop.

Grouped Articles

Fareed Zakaria: Let’s be honest, Islam has a problem right now - The Washington Post

Washington Post 10/10/2014

How Tunisia Will Succeed

New York Times 11/19/2014

Teaching Islam’s ‘Forgotten’ Side as Germany Changes

New York Times 01/09/2015

After Terrorist Attacks, Many French Muslims Wonder: What Now?

New York Times 01/10/2015

The Roots of the Migration Crisis

Wall Street Journal 09/11/2015


Support LyrArc

We took a different way to help millions around the world build educated informed mindsets that affects and shapes their lives. For a future that is open, global and digital, with everyone having access to high quality information. We believe in the renewal of America, renewal of Europe, the renewal of India, the rest of Asia, Latin America and Africa. The renewal of our supply chains, health, education, infrastructure, as we rebuild our countries after the pandemic. Literacy and knowledge we believe cannot thrive and grow in a world of web bots, web crawlers, or AI. This requires human curiosity, human learning, and human imagination. We take as inspiration the saying- “One has to be free, and as broad as sky. One has to have a mind that is crystal clear, only then can truth shine in it.” Every contribution whether big or small is precious- in this crisis and ahead.

Support Lyrarc from as small as $1


Copyright © 2006 - 2026 Intelilinks LLC
Terms and Conditions | Copyright Policy | Privacy Policy | Contact Us