World News Insights
1-3 Minute Gist

All Topics Article

Middle East Challenges Obama’s ‘Light Footprint’

New York Times Original article ›

Keywords:

LyrArc Article Gist
Critics of the Obama administration's so-called "light footprint strategy" for the Middle East say it is more about keeping distance from problems in that region. This is a reaction to the extensive involvement of the U.S. in two wars in that region and intuitively makes sense, as well as being in line with American public opinion to focus on problems at home. The shift or pivot to Asia of president Obama also comes in that context. The problem with this approach is that this ignores the fact that most of the momentum and effort for the freedom struggles throughout the Middle East from Tunisia first, then Libya, Egypt, and now Syria, comes from within. The lead role is now being taken by France and Britain, with German public opinion also lined up in support. The U.S. in forfeiting its role as a facilitator with strategies such as "no-fly-zones" is losing the opportunity to gain the goodwill in the Middle East with cost that is negligible in comparison to the cost of Iraq and Afghanistan, and comes after the huge U.S. effort to remove one dictator in Iraq. A minor followup effort is all that is required from an administration that pushed for the "surge" in Afghanistan. When history is written the investment of the Obama administration in Afghanistan may show little results, if what is considered by the media and experts as an unpopular and undemocratic government of Karzai falls in the aftermath of the U.S. withdrawal. There is little doubt in public opinion in the U.S. and worldwide that the movement for freedom and democracy in the Middle East and democratically elected governments will become a lasting facet of the new Middle East. It also provides huge opportunties for trade and investment as is shown by the gains made by Turkey in just 2 years. This is why the Obama adminstration policies in the Middle East show a lack of grasp of the facts showing the Middle East as opportunity more than threat for the next decade, especially in its overreaction to the Bush era policies. This happens as there is a demographic explosion of young people in the Middle East. An administration that was keen to sense the demographic changes in North America, has failed to grasp this fact and why the struggle in the Middle East flashes daily on television screens young people carrying on the struggle. A pivot to Asia means a pivot to the Far East more than Asia because India is part of the South Asian-Middle Eastern region, which presents another paradox because as China is slowing the entire South Asian-Middle Eastern region of Asia is where future growth is expected to accelerate in the next decade.

Calls for President Obama to act decisively in Libya.

03/05/2011

The March 7, 2011 Wall Street Journal editorial calls for military action in Libya to prevent the Ghadafi regime from suppressing the democracy protests inside Libya. Other calls for action from Senators McConnell, McCain, and Kerry over the weekend March 5-6. The slow and hesitant response of the Obama administration.

Grouped Articles

Leading From Behind Congress

Wall Street Journal 09/01/2013

Leaving U.S. Allies Adrift as Chaos Rises

Wall Street Journal 08/01/2014

Turkish Inaction on ISIS Advance Dismays the U.S.

New York Times 10/07/2014

The saddest piece of Barack Obama’s legacy - The Washington Post

Washington Post 04/18/2016

Obama's Libyan Abdication

Wall Street Journal 03/06/2011

U.S. Debates Libya Action

Wall Street Journal 03/09/2011

The failure to protect the American diplomatic mission in Benghazi, Libya

08/25/2011

A series of failures and misleading statements by the Obama administration on the burning of the American consulate in Benghazi, Libya, by terrorists, and the death of diplomats.

Grouped Articles

At Benghazi hearing, State Dept. officials challenge administration review of attacks - The Washington Post

Washington Post 05/09/2013

Diplomat Airs Benghazi Attack Details

Wall Street Journal 05/09/2013

Benghazi E-Mails Put White House on the Defensive

New York Times 05/10/2013

The Deeper Blame for Benghazi

New York Times 05/13/2013

What we’ve learned in Libya - The Washington Post

Washington Post 08/25/2011

A White House Under Siege

Wall Street Journal 05/22/2013

The Theatre of Lies in U.S. policies towards the Middle East and South Asia

07/24/2010

With the huge cost of two wars in the region and failure to support democracy and economic opportunity in the region, questions about what the U.S. government is saying and the underlying realities. The failure of two administrations from opposite parties, and one with idealistic pretensions to do nothing more than continue old policies that utterly fail the people of the region.

Grouped Articles

‘Beyond War,’ by David Rohde

New York Times 05/03/2013

The War: A Trillion Can Be Cheap

New York Times 07/24/2010

A Festival of Lies

New York Times 03/24/2012

Feith and Cropsey: A Foreign Policy Failure to Acknowledge the Obvious

Wall Street Journal 10/18/2012

Middle East Challenges Obama’s ‘Light Footprint’

New York Times 11/17/2012

Wallflowers at the Revolution

New York Times 02/05/2011

A must read from soviet archives about a Soviet general making the same request McChrystal is making.

10/20/2008

With 110,000 troops in Afghnistan, Soviet general Akhromeyev made the request for more troops in the seventh year of a nine year Soviet Afghan conflict. The Soviets could not maintain political control outside the provincial capitals as the insurgents simply disappeared into the hills, in so vast a country, is how he put it to the Soviet Politburo. In th same manner Russian Ambassador to Kabul, Kabulov, who was the KGB chief in Kabul during the soviet Afghan conflict, says there is an "irrtitive allergy" to foreigners for Afghans in the villages and hills that makes a large foreign presence costly and dangerous approach. A must read as the US is at a similiar juncture in its version of the Afghan conflict, and bad choices could prove very costly for the country as it did for the soviets.

Grouped Articles

McChrystal article renews attention to split with Biden over Afghanistan

Washington Post 06/23/2010

Weakening, possible firing of McChrystal compounds sense of peril in Afghanistan

Washington Post 06/23/2010

An Old Afghanistan Hand Offers Lessons of the Past

New York Times 10/20/2008

Transcripts of Defeat

New York Times 10/29/2009

Soviets' Afghan Ordeal Vexed Gates on Troop-Surge Plan

Wall Street Journal 11/30/2009

SAP Readies Software for RIM's New Tablet

Wall Street Journal 11/20/2010

Spillover effects for Iraq, Turkey, Lebanon, Saudi Arabia and the U.S. from the civil war in Syria- Sept-Nov. 2012 and by 2014

05/21/2011

The Syrian civil war is spilling over into Iraq. Iraq is unable to protect its airspace from being used by Iran to ship supplies to the Assad regime, or to prevent Turkey's warplanes from using Iraqi airspace to attack Kurdish separatists. There is also a danger of a Sunni-Shiite conflict being exacerabated by former Sunni insurgents in Iraq joining up with Sunni refugees from Syria. The Maliki government in Iraq is moving closer to Iran as the Syrian civil war escalates and brings Sunnis together against the Assad regime. Turkey is also seeing the effects of a flow of refugees on its border with Syria. The Obama administration has been slow to respond to the rapidly developing situation as it concentrates on a complete withdrawal of U.S. forces from Iraq with the lack of agreement on a residual U.S. troop presence. This leaves the U.S. less than the minimum leverage that is needed just as the sectarian divisions are worsening, after years of investing resources in the region. With the EU countries focussed on economic problems, and the Obama administration's lack of active support for the Free Syria movement, the broader involvement of Iran, Iraq, Turkey, Saudi Arabia, and Russia in the region, the situation is likely to lead to an international crisis without U.S. leadership.

Grouped Articles

More Help for Syrian Rebels

New York Times 04/22/2013

Clashes Carry Worries of a New Civil War

New York Times 04/28/2013

‘Beyond War,’ by David Rohde

New York Times 05/03/2013

Pentagon Plans for the Worst in Syria

Wall Street Journal 05/07/2013

What if the U.S. doesn’t intervene in Syria? - The Washington Post

Washington Post 05/09/2013

Why did Mr. Obama overrule his advisers on Syria? - The Washington Post

Washington Post 05/09/2013

Criticism of the Obama administration's hesitant response to the protests in Egypt

01/28/2011

Vice President Biden says "I would not call Mubarak a dictator." President Obama fails to take a clear position in support of democracy, freedom of expression and economic opportunity in Egypt.

Grouped Articles

Military Madness in Cairo

New York Times 08/14/2013

Adrift on the Nile

New York Times 08/25/2013

Rice Offers a More Modest Strategy for Mideast

New York Times 10/26/2013

Leaving U.S. Allies Adrift as Chaos Rises

Wall Street Journal 08/01/2014

How Do You Solve a Problem Like Mubarak

New York Times 01/28/2011

The U.S. needs to break with Mubarak now

Washington Post 01/29/2011

Demographic explosion of young people in the Arab world

06/03/2009

What this means for government, democracy, job creation and economic opportunity in the Arab world.

Grouped Articles

Amid population boom, India hopes for ‘demographic dividend’ but fears disaster - The Washington Post

Washington Post 10/18/2011

Education vs. Extremism

Wall Street Journal 06/03/2009

Islam and demography: A waxing crescent

Economist 02/21/2011

George W. Bush: The Arab Spring and American Ideals

Wall Street Journal 05/17/2012

Middle East Challenges Obama’s ‘Light Footprint’

New York Times 11/17/2012

Fractured Lands: How the Arab World Came Apart

08/11/2016


Support LyrArc

We took a different way to help millions around the world build educated informed mindsets that affects and shapes their lives. For a future that is open, global and digital, with everyone having access to high quality information. We believe in the renewal of America, renewal of Europe, the renewal of India, the rest of Asia, Latin America and Africa. The renewal of our supply chains, health, education, infrastructure, as we rebuild our countries after the pandemic. Literacy and knowledge we believe cannot thrive and grow in a world of web bots, web crawlers, or AI. This requires human curiosity, human learning, and human imagination. We take as inspiration the saying- “One has to be free, and as broad as sky. One has to have a mind that is crystal clear, only then can truth shine in it.” Every contribution whether big or small is precious- in this crisis and ahead.

Support Lyrarc from as small as $1


Copyright © 2006 - 2026 Intelilinks LLC
Terms and Conditions | Copyright Policy | Privacy Policy | Contact Us