World News Insights
1-3 Minute Gist

All Topics Article

Afghan Army’s High Turnover Clouds U.S. Exit Plan

New York Times Original article ›

Keywords:

LyrArc Article Gist
The high risk of failure as the U.S. withdraws from Afghanistan in 2012-2013. The U.S. is handing over to an Afghan Army that faces a high desertion rate, high turnover, and uncertain loyalties. The turnover is so high that the Afghan Army has to replace a third of the 195,000 army every year. The problems from the corruption in the Karzai government, the flawed elections, and other issues have not been resolved, leaving a fragile government and a fragile army and police force as the U.S. withdraws. A decade of sacrifices in resources, lives and wounded, is at risk. A negotiated settlement in talks with the Taliban has not moved forward to create a post U.S. withdrawal Afghan government that brings in all parties. The untimely death of American diplomat Holbrooke who set up the accord that made peace in the Balkans, and the failure to get results at the talks only leaves the whole U.S. project at risk.

The facts about the Afghan Army the U.S. hands over to with the withdrawal in 2012- high risk of failure

10/15/2012

High desertion rate, high turnover, and other problems with the Afghan Army that the U.S. is handing over to with the withdrawal in 2012-2013. The increasing probability that the Afghan Army will fail to maintain control after the U.S. withdraws. The Karzai government has never tackled corruption and the issues arising from a flawed election leaving it without the kind of popular support it would need after the U.S. withdraws. The negotiations with the Taliban and the opposition have failed to produce any agreement on a post U.S withdrawal Afghanistan, putting the entire U.S. sacrifices in Afghanistan in lives lost, wounded veterans, and in the cost of the war at risk

Grouped Articles

Pakistan to Release Senior Taliban Leader

Wall Street Journal 09/11/2013

Leader of Pakistani Taliban Killed in Drone Strike

Wall Street Journal 11/02/2013

Gates Faults Obama Over Afghanistan

Wall Street Journal 01/08/2014

U.S. Military Eyes Afghan Force of 10,000, or a Pullout

New York Times 01/21/2014

U.S. Will Complete Afghan Pullout by End of 2016, Obama Says

New York Times 05/27/2014

Obama Details Plan for Forces in Afghanistan

Wall Street Journal 05/28/2014

Obama and Holbrooke: A Missed Opportunity

01/04/2008

Holbrooke grasped from his long experience in overseas conflicts what the best solution would be for Afghanistan- a negotiated settlement with the Taliban and Pakistan's army. The lack of White House support to the negotiator of the Dayton Peace accords in Bosnia, will remain a puzzling aspect of a landscape in America's costly involvement in two wars. Holbrooke's larger than life personality and style was the same under President Clinton who tapped Holbrooke's skills in America's interest and ignored posssible distractions. The failure of Obama to do the same and accomodate the personality to tap the vast trove of experience and wisdom of Holbrooke in a national crisis of two ongoing wars, is a comment on the nature of the leadership offered by the two presidents. It is a loss for America that goes unnoticed.

Grouped Articles

Pakistan to Release Senior Taliban Leader

Wall Street Journal 09/11/2013

Ex-Envoy Says Misunderstanding Runs on Both Sides of U.S.-Pakistan Ties

New York Times 10/22/2013

Sharif and Karzai Try to Repair Ties

Wall Street Journal 10/30/2013

Leader of Pakistani Taliban Killed in Drone Strike

Wall Street Journal 11/02/2013

Gates Faults Obama Over Afghanistan

Wall Street Journal 01/08/2014

Back on World Stage, a Larger-Than-Life Holbrooke

New York Times 02/08/2009

The Eikenberry cables and the war in Afghanistan.

11/28/2009

The language is strong and rejects McChrystal's appraisal that additional troops can make the difference considering the failure of the Karzai government and the poor prospects for the Afghan army.

Grouped Articles

McChrystal article renews attention to split with Biden over Afghanistan

Washington Post 06/23/2010

Weakening, possible firing of McChrystal compounds sense of peril in Afghanistan

Washington Post 06/23/2010

Afghan Crisis Risks Splitting Country

Wall Street Journal 07/09/2014

Afghans Offer Jobs to Taliban Rank and File if They Defect

New York Times 11/28/2009

Afghan Tribe, Vowing to Fight Taliban, to Get U.S. Aid in Return

New York Times 01/28/2010

U.S. Envoy’s Cables Show Worries on Afghan Plans

New York Times 01/26/2010

Filkins describes a crumbling feudal order of maliks left by the British which makes Afghanistan an even more dangerous place for an American project.

09/07/2008

Dexter Filkins points to another factor in Afghanistan. Not only is there a double game- see the link to Playing the Game- where the army, the ISI and many ordinary Muslims in Pakistan are sympathetic to fellow Muslims fighting the Americans, but there is a social change in process. This may be even more dangerous, as the British left a feudal order intact in Pakistan with a wealthy landholding class, In the Pathan or Pashtun countryside it was run through tribal elders called Maliks, in the Punjab the wealthy feudal landholding ran things pretty much the same way as the British did for the last 50 years. Dexter Filkins points to the crumbling of this structure in the Pathan (Pashtun) countryside.

Grouped Articles

Right at the Edge

New York Times 09/07/2008

Afghanistan Army Tries to Attract Southern Pashtuns

New York Times 09/06/2011

Afghan Myths, 10 Years In

New York Times 10/07/2011

A New Pakistan Policy: Containment

New York Times 10/14/2011

Book review: ‘The Unquiet American: Richard Holbrooke in the World’ - The Washington Post

Washington Post 11/13/2011

The Afghan Surge Is Over - By Rajiv Chandrasekaran | Foreign Policy

Unknown 09/26/2012

The Pakistan Army and the U.S.

01/07/2008

The increasingly difficult position of General Kayani as he loses support from the rank and file in the army and junior officers on the issue of cooperation with the U.S. Admiral Mullen's criticism of Pakistan after the attacks on the U.S. Embassy in Kabul with the help of Pakistan's intelligence agency ISI.

Grouped Articles

Pakistan Vote to Test Army's Willingness to Cede Power

Wall Street Journal 05/09/2013

Ex-Envoy Says Misunderstanding Runs on Both Sides of U.S.-Pakistan Ties

New York Times 10/22/2013

Visiting Pakistan, Hagel Seeks to Shore Up Alliance

New York Times 12/09/2013

Pakistani forces kill alleged organizer of school massacre - The Washington Post

Washington Post 12/27/2014

Hamid Gul, 78, Dies; Backed Militants in Leading Pakistan Spy Agency

New York Times 08/16/2015

General Kayani Is Said to Cling to Job in Pakistan

New York Times 06/15/2011


Support LyrArc

We took a different way to help millions around the world build educated informed mindsets that affects and shapes their lives. For a future that is open, global and digital, with everyone having access to high quality information. We believe in the renewal of America, renewal of Europe, the renewal of India, the rest of Asia, Latin America and Africa. The renewal of our supply chains, health, education, infrastructure, as we rebuild our countries after the pandemic. Literacy and knowledge we believe cannot thrive and grow in a world of web bots, web crawlers, or AI. This requires human curiosity, human learning, and human imagination. We take as inspiration the saying- “One has to be free, and as broad as sky. One has to have a mind that is crystal clear, only then can truth shine in it.” Every contribution whether big or small is precious- in this crisis and ahead.

Support Lyrarc from as small as $1


Copyright © 2006 - 2026 Intelilinks LLC
Terms and Conditions | Copyright Policy | Privacy Policy | Contact Us