World News Insights
1-3 Minute Gist
Search, personalize, or simply browse. Follow the world around you from gist and context to insights.
Who we are | Our Credo | Ways of using Lyrarc | FAQ | Send Feedback | First Letter From the Editor
Sign up. It's free and easy to use
Create an account
to personalize your feed of articles and topics.
All Topics Article
Raters Fail to See Defaults Coming
Keywords:
A Wall Street Journal Survey of how the credit ratings firms have performed in prediciting looming defaults. The Journal's Matt Wirz looked at 35 years of data. He found the ratings firms did not do an effective job with predicting defaults in the 12 month period before an actual default. Of the 15 government defaults since 1975 tracked by S&P, S&P's sovereign ratings division rated 12 of the countries single B or higher in the 12 months preceding the default. S&P says a single-B rating on sovereign debt signifies that the government has only a 2% average default rate in the next 12 months. For Moody's Investors Service the figures show that of the 13 governments rated by Moody's, 11 were rated B or higher one year before an actual default. By contrast the investment grade ratings of the credit ratings firms have worked better- as no government defaulted within 15 years of having a tripe-A, double-A, or a single-A rating. Ratings firms say that the ratings indicate a relative default risk for countries and not an actual default probability, a rank ordering for different countries and their relative risk. Research chiefs at investment management firms point out that once a crisis develops the ratings firms are not much help. They also say the ratings firms use static indicators like current account balances and other critical indicators for countries in emerging markets such as political sentiment and bank deposit flows get less attention. Historically bond yields have priced in higher risk premiums into government bonds before a default and investors look at the bond yields in assessing risk conditions, and not at the ratings which change only slowly. Brazil and Argentina both had a double B-minus rating in Jan. 2001. A year later Argentina had defaulted.
Wall Street Journal study of the performance of credit ratings firms for sovereign defaults since 1975
08/12/2011
A review of the performance of the sovereign ratings units of S&P, Moody's Investors Service and Fitch Ratings, shows the ratings firms did poorly in predicting defaults in the 12 months preceding the actual default. The ratings take into account static indicators such as current account balances but pay less attention to political changes and bank deposit flows. Investment managers turn to changes in bond yields for government debt as a better indicator of default conditions.
Grouped Articles
Rating Firms Steer Clear of an Overhaul
Wall Street Journal 05/12/2013
A Warning Light to Alert the I.M.F.
New York Times 09/21/2011
What Crisis? Big Ratings Firms Stronger Than Ever
Wall Street Journal 03/10/2016
Raters Fail to See Defaults Coming
Wall Street Journal 08/12/2011
New S&P Chief Knows Crisis and Change
New York Times 08/24/2011
At S&P, a Crusader for Tough Ratings
Wall Street Journal 10/05/2011
Reaction in financial markets to the U.S. credit rating downgrade to AA+
01/16/2009
The downgrade by credit ratings agency S&P for U.S. Treasury securities on August 5, 2011. The downgrade had been expected for several weeks as debt ceiling negotiations in Congress dragged on in July 2011.
Grouped Articles
S&P's Lack of Sway on Display in U.S. Move
Wall Street Journal 06/11/2013
S&P's Account of An Irate Treasury Secretary
New York Times 01/21/2014
For Markets, 'Lehman Effect' Not Likely
Wall Street Journal 08/06/2011
The Downgrading of a Debtor Nation
New York Times 08/08/2011
The system works - The Washington Post
Washington Post 08/12/2011
Raters Fail to See Defaults Coming
Wall Street Journal 08/12/2011
S&P
08/12/2011
Grouped Articles
Raters Fail to See Defaults Coming
Wall Street Journal 08/12/2011
New S&P Chief Knows Crisis and Change
New York Times 08/24/2011
At S&P, a Crusader for Tough Ratings
Wall Street Journal 10/05/2011
Wall Street Journal 12/09/2011
Wall Street Journal 02/05/2013
S. & P. E-Mails on Mortgage Crisis Show Alarm and Gallows Humor
New York Times 02/05/2013
History of the credit ratings industry structure and how a few firms dominate
08/10/2011
Grouped Articles
What Crisis? Big Ratings Firms Stronger Than Ever
Wall Street Journal 03/10/2016
Call to Downsize Giants of Ratings
Wall Street Journal 08/10/2011
Raters Fail to See Defaults Coming
Wall Street Journal 08/12/2011
At S&P, a Crusader for Tough Ratings
Wall Street Journal 10/05/2011
Moody's Investors Service performance
12/07/2008
Grouped Articles
Debt Watchdogs: Tamed or Caught Napping?
New York Times 12/07/2008
Raters Fail to See Defaults Coming
Wall Street Journal 08/12/2011
Moody's Cuts Credit Ratings of 15 Big Banks
New York Times 06/21/2012
Moody's Defends Bank Rating Cuts
Wall Street Journal 06/23/2012
Vows of Change at Moody's, but Flaws Remain the Same
New York Times 04/14/2011
Fitch Ratings
08/12/2011
Grouped Articles
Raters Fail to See Defaults Coming
Wall Street Journal 08/12/2011
Why Wall Street Can't Handle the Truth
Wall Street Journal 11/05/2011
Italy Called Biggest Euro-Zone Threat
Wall Street Journal 01/11/2012
S&P and credit rating for U.S. debt
07/22/2011
Grouped Articles
S&P's Account of An Irate Treasury Secretary
New York Times 01/21/2014
S&P Nears Settlement on Real-Estate Bond Ratings
Wall Street Journal 12/26/2014
Making the Call on U.S. Credit Rating
Wall Street Journal 07/22/2011
Wall Street Journal 07/23/2011
S&P downgrades U.S. credit rating for first time - The Washington Post
Washington Post 08/06/2011
S&P's Rationale for Downgrading the U.S.
New York Times 08/06/2011
S&P performance
08/11/2011
Grouped Articles
McGraw Hill Financial Results Top Views on Rating Service Strength
Wall Street Journal 07/30/2014
S.&P. Nears Settlement With Justice Over Inflated Ratings
New York Times 01/12/2015
S.&P.'s $1.37 Billion Reckoning Over Crisis-Era Misdeeds
New York Times 02/03/2015
Wall Street Journal 08/11/2011
Raters Fail to See Defaults Coming
Wall Street Journal 08/12/2011
New S&P Chief Knows Crisis and Change
New York Times 08/24/2011
Credit Ratings firms and the U.S. and Eurozone financial crisis of 2010-2012
12/08/2009
Criticism of credit ratings firms. European commissioner Barnier calls for banning credit raings on countries receiving financial aid after Moody's strongly downgraded Protugal's debt ratingin July 2011. The problems of credit ratings being very pro-cyclical and the need to reduce the role of ratings in the market and regulatory framework in Europe.
Grouped Articles
ECB Chief Seeks Tighter Fiscal Union
Wall Street Journal 06/22/2010
What Crisis? Big Ratings Firms Stronger Than Ever
Wall Street Journal 03/10/2016
Ratings Gag Is No Joking Matter
Wall Street Journal 07/12/2011
Debt Raters Avoid Overhaul After Crisis
New York Times 12/08/2009
Wall Street Journal 07/23/2011
S&P downgrades U.S. credit rating for first time - The Washington Post
Washington Post 08/06/2011
Moody's
12/07/2008
Grouped Articles
Debt Watchdogs: Tamed or Caught Napping?
New York Times 12/07/2008
Moody's Tops Profit Forecasts, Shares Rally
Wall Street Journal 04/28/2011
Debt Raters Avoid Overhaul After Crisis
New York Times 12/08/2009
Raters Fail to See Defaults Coming
Wall Street Journal 08/12/2011
Wall Street Journal 06/22/2012
Moody's Defends Bank Rating Cuts
Wall Street Journal 06/23/2012
Fitch Ratings performance
08/12/2011
Grouped Articles
Raters Fail to See Defaults Coming
Wall Street Journal 08/12/2011
Italy Called Biggest Euro-Zone Threat
Wall Street Journal 01/11/2012
We took a different way to help millions around the world build educated informed mindsets that affects and shapes their lives. For a future that is open, global and digital, with everyone having access to high quality information. We believe in the renewal of America, renewal of Europe, the renewal of India, the rest of Asia, Latin America and Africa. The renewal of our supply chains, health, education, infrastructure, as we rebuild our countries after the pandemic. Literacy and knowledge we believe cannot thrive and grow in a world of web bots, web crawlers, or AI. This requires human curiosity, human learning, and human imagination. We take as inspiration the saying- “One has to be free, and as broad as sky. One has to have a mind that is crystal clear, only then can truth shine in it.” Every contribution whether big or small is precious- in this crisis and ahead.
Support Lyrarc from as small as $1
Terms and Conditions | Copyright Policy | Privacy Policy | Contact Us