World News Insights
1-3 Minute Gist

All Topics Article

Why Kids Can’t Write

The New York Times Original article ›
LyrArc Article Gist
Dana Goldstein of the NYT looks at the big problem in education today- the failure to teach reading and writing skills to students in American schools. Goldstein cites two alarming statistics. About 40% of students who took the ACT writing exam in the high school class of 2016 lack the reading and writing skills to pass a college level composition class in English. 8th and 12th grade classes in the U.S. have 75% of the students lacking writing skills proficiency, according to the National Assessment of Educational Progress.

Of the 1204 comments to this article in the NYT, many of the 17 selected by NYT say the problem is that students lack reading skills. Other problems shown here are the handicaps created by technology, yes technology. Mobile phone use is common and this is done quickly with the least attention to write good sentences, little attention to punctuation, spelling or grammar. Half or incomplete sentences are easier to type on mobile, so a new generation grows up thinking that this is normal. As a result a whole generation of kids have not learned to read or write well, constructing sentences with limited vocabulary. Steve Jobs and Apple may say that iPads and iPhones, smartphones and other tech devices have advanced reading with the beautiful display technology screens, but this is not what is really happening. Google may say that its search helps people access good reading materials, and this too is not what is really happening. 

Equally alarming is that there is no clear agreement on how to tackle this problem. The No Child Left Behind 2002 law set a program emphasizing reading and use of multiple choice questions to test reading skills. This was followed by the Common Core standards now implemented in schools for 6 years that shift the focus to writing. Yet the results are still the same, showing little progress.

Goodman cites as examples of disagreement, the Writing Revolution project which focusses on grammar and other writing skills, and the Long Island Writing Project that focusses on students finding their own voice by freewriting. A student in the freewriting class which encourages finding your own voice, expresses her frustration by saying she doesn't hear a voice- what voice, she asks. 

One of the problems is that teachers themselves lack writing skills. A look at 2400 teacher preparation programs shows little attention paid to teaching writing. The head of the Reading and Writing Project at Columbia University's Teachers College, says Common Core failed in implementation of massive teacher training, which is required to address the problem.

As a result remediation programs are needed badly in colleges to fix literacy skills, when better teaching would have prevented the problem in the first place.

Little understood or debated is that every generation has to learn about the country's democratic institutions, every generation has to make its own effort to gain civic literacy- it is not something that can be taken for granted or handed down from one generation to the next. Without reading and learning about how these institutions function, young people lack the skills for participating in our democracy and in the global economy.


Vocabulary and reading in American education

02/20/2009

Grouped Articles

Competing visions

Economist 02/20/2009

Learning to Read, With the Help of a Tablet

New York Times 08/21/2013

Librarian’s Love of Books Began in Her Struggles to Read

New York Times 10/15/2013

The Great Gift of Reading Aloud

Wall Street Journal 07/15/2015

Long Line at the Library? It’s Story Time Again

New York Times 11/01/2015

Students Fall Flat in Vocabulary Test

Wall Street Journal 12/07/2012

The demand for children's reading activities at New York neighborhood branch libraries in 2015

11/01/2015

Grouped Articles

Long Line at the Library? It’s Story Time Again

New York Times 11/01/2015

Why Kids Can’t Write

The New York Times 08/02/2017

iPads vs. paper books for reading to children or how to integrate iPads with paper books and libraries for a fuller experience

10/11/2014

The role of reading in a child's development is crucial for the child's future, with parents reading to children an activity to be encouraged and fostered by society in every way. How can parents use electronic technology of iPads to shift some of the television time to the wider selection of books and programs of educational value for children? Training children to make wise and useful choices of educational value from the wide proliferating selection on the internet is itself an exercize that is needed, just as the exercize of showing children how to make wise and useful eating choices is needed.

Grouped Articles

Is E-Reading to Your Toddler Story Time, or Simply Screen Time?

New York Times 10/11/2014

The Great Gift of Reading Aloud

Wall Street Journal 07/15/2015

Long Line at the Library? It’s Story Time Again

New York Times 11/01/2015

Why Kids Can’t Write

The New York Times 08/02/2017

Reading books on literature, history, philosopy, religion and science to expand one's horizons

01/12/2012

Reading to understand the world around us and the worlds before our time.

Grouped Articles

Librarian’s Love of Books Began in Her Struggles to Read

New York Times 10/15/2013

The Great Gift of Reading Aloud

Wall Street Journal 07/15/2015

A Harvard Medical School professor makes the case for the liberal arts and philosophy - The Washington Post

Washington Post 12/25/2015

What literary challenges have you conquered? - The Washington Post

Washington Post 01/12/2012

Why Kids Can’t Write

The New York Times 08/02/2017

Silicon Valley and education standards in the U.S.- the Common Core program for higher student scores in math and reading

07/22/2013

Grouped Articles

U.S. Schools Chief Arne Duncan Labors to Straddle Political Divide

Wall Street Journal 07/22/2013

War on the Core

New York Times 08/18/2013

Obama’s Homework Assignment

New York Times 01/18/2014

Republicans See Political Wedge in Common Core

New York Times 04/19/2014

Why Silicon Valley Will Continue to Rule the Tech Economy

Wall Street Journal 08/23/2014

English Class in Common Core Era: ‘Tom Sawyer’ and Court Opinions

New York Times 06/19/2015

"Don't take books out, it's so expensive"- the library systems in San Jose with exorbitant late fees compared to San Francisco and New York's even more welcoming attitude

03/30/2016

The American Library Association and librarians in most parts of America sees the goal of libraries to increase access to books, especially low income families without broad band connections. The situation in San Jose described by Carol Pogash in the NYT is shocking because it discourages young people from taking out books, with parents on low incomes unable to handle the excessive late fees. At a time when America's goal should be to lift the next generation of low income families, especially immigrants, and integrate them better in society, libraries in low income parts of San Jose are in a situation where some are described as deserted because of late fees. San Francisco charges significantly less in late fees. And New York uses more reading time spent in the library as a way to pay off late fees. An approach taken by some libraries is to not impose late fees on people under the age of 16.

Grouped Articles

In San Jose, Poor Find Doors to Library Closed

New York Times 03/30/2016

Why Kids Can’t Write

The New York Times 08/02/2017


Support LyrArc

We took a different way to help millions around the world build educated informed mindsets that affects and shapes their lives. For a future that is open, global and digital, with everyone having access to high quality information. We believe in the renewal of America, renewal of Europe, the renewal of India, the rest of Asia, Latin America and Africa. The renewal of our supply chains, health, education, infrastructure, as we rebuild our countries after the pandemic. Literacy and knowledge we believe cannot thrive and grow in a world of web bots, web crawlers, or AI. This requires human curiosity, human learning, and human imagination. We take as inspiration the saying- “One has to be free, and as broad as sky. One has to have a mind that is crystal clear, only then can truth shine in it.” Every contribution whether big or small is precious- in this crisis and ahead.

Support Lyrarc from as small as $1


Copyright © 2006 - 2026 Intelilinks LLC
Terms and Conditions | Copyright Policy | Privacy Policy | Contact Us