World News Insights
1-3 Minute Gist

All Topics Article

Egypt's Economic Apartheid

Wall Street Journal Original article ›

Keywords:

LyrArc Article Gist
Hernando De Soto, a prominent economist, heads the Institute for Liberty and Democracy. He has an intimate knowledge of the workings of the Egyptian economy, and describes the socio-economic marginalization of large parts of Egyptian society as Economic Apartheid. Simply put Egypt has fallen behind the times, way behind the economic progress in large developing countries.The Institute was hired by the Egyptian government in 1997, with the financial support of the US Agency for International Development, to look into what reforms were needed. It presented its 1000 page report in 2004- after years of work involving 120 Egyptian and Peruvian technicians, participation of 300 local leaders and interviews with thousands of ordinary people- to the Egyptian cabinet. The then Finance Minister Hassanein supported it and the cabinet approved it. What followed was a cabinet shakeup, and blocking of any reforms by hidden interests wanting to protect the status quo. De Soto's objective was to find out how many people were marginalized in Egypt, and how much of the economy operated outside the legal system- small business that did not have the protection of property rights or access to normal business tools and credit, that makes businesses grow. He found that 9.6 million people were employed in this sector operating "extralegally" with no protections. This being the largest sector of employment in Egypt. His action plan was intended to remove the legal impediments to these people and businesses urban and rural, so that they could grow. He says the value of these businesses outside legal protections is $248 billion or 30 times larger than the total value on the Cairo stock exchange, and 55 times greater than all the foreign direct investment in Egypt since 1800 including Suez Canal and Aswan Dam. De Soto says that because of burdensome, discriminatory and bad laws it takes 500 days to open a small bakery, getting a legal title on a vacant piece of land would take 10 years of red tape. This barrier of bad laws, poorly trained bureaucrats, inertia of the status quo, prevents people from legalizing their property and business. As a result whereas one of these types of small businesses is now India's largest company called Reliance Industries, and another Infosys is the second largest software company, most Egyptian enterprises are stuck being small and relatively poor, and do not generate jobs for the demographic surge of young people. De Soto's point is that Egypt will need good leadership to pull off this task of legal reform, and democracy alone will not be enough. Empowering the large majority of the Egyptian people operating outside the legal protections will mean giving property rights for $400 billion of assets, De Soto says. And this would unlock an amount of capital hundreds of times larger than what foreign direct investment and aid has brought to the country.

Egypt's Economic Apartheid- the antiquated legal system keeps $400 billion of the people's assets outside of the economy

06/03/2009

Hernando Soto conducted a detailed study on reforming the antiquated Egyptian legal system and the bureaucratic red tape that cripples the economy and leaves the Egyptian people without hope. It was presented to the Egyptian government for reforms in 2004, then the cabinet was reshuffled and reforms were blocked by hidden interests interested in preserving the status quo. The economic crisis facing Egypt after years of underinvestment in the economy.

Grouped Articles

Qatar's Aid to Egypt Raises Fears on Motives

Wall Street Journal 05/19/2013

Egypt Premier Known as Free-Market Champion

Wall Street Journal 07/10/2013

The Economic Blunders Behind the Arab Revolutions

Wall Street Journal 07/12/2013

Egypt's Economic Apartheid

Wall Street Journal 02/03/2011

Change in Egypt and Property and Political Rights

Wall Street Journal 02/08/2011

Education vs. Extremism

Wall Street Journal 06/03/2009

Education and high unemployment for young people in Egypt

02/02/2011

The economic crisis facing Egypt as it runs out of foreign reserves, and after years of underinvestment in the economy.

Grouped Articles

Qatar's Aid to Egypt Raises Fears on Motives

Wall Street Journal 05/19/2013

Egypt Premier Known as Free-Market Champion

Wall Street Journal 07/10/2013

The Economic Blunders Behind the Arab Revolutions

Wall Street Journal 07/12/2013

Arab World Built Colleges, but Not Jobs

Wall Street Journal 02/05/2011

The Youth Unemployment Bomb

BusinessWeek 02/02/2011

Bottom of the pyramid

Economist 09/10/2011

Egypt and wheat imports

02/03/2011

The economic crisis facing Egypt after years of underinvestment in the economy.

Grouped Articles

Qatar's Aid to Egypt Raises Fears on Motives

Wall Street Journal 05/19/2013

Egypt Premier Known as Free-Market Champion

Wall Street Journal 07/10/2013

The Economic Blunders Behind the Arab Revolutions

Wall Street Journal 07/12/2013

Egypt Suffers From Shortage of Dollars

Wall Street Journal 02/02/2016

Egypt Faces Food Supply Worries

Wall Street Journal 08/04/2011

Egypt's Economy Reels as Capital Flees

BusinessWeek 12/01/2011

Egypt's economy- 2010-2013

01/28/2011

The economic crisis facing Egypt after years of underinvestment in the economy.

Grouped Articles

Egypt Premier Known as Free-Market Champion

Wall Street Journal 07/10/2013

Egypt's Regime on the Brink

Wall Street Journal 01/28/2011

U.S. Threatens to Cut Off Aid to Egypt

Wall Street Journal 01/28/2011

A Long March to Seize the Heart of Cairo

Wall Street Journal 01/29/2011

Egypt's Regime on the Brink

Wall Street Journal 01/29/2011

Moment of Truth for U.S.

Wall Street Journal 01/29/2011

Egypt's central bank running out of reserves in 2011-2013

02/03/2011

The economic crisis facing Egypt after years of underinvestment in the economy.

Grouped Articles

Qatar's Aid to Egypt Raises Fears on Motives

Wall Street Journal 05/19/2013

Egypt Premier Known as Free-Market Champion

Wall Street Journal 07/10/2013

The Economic Blunders Behind the Arab Revolutions

Wall Street Journal 07/12/2013

Egypt’s Military to Lend $1 Billion to Bolster Currency

New York Times 12/28/2011

Muslim Brotherhood Looks West in Bid to Revive Egyptian Economy

Wall Street Journal 02/17/2012

Tumult Trips Egypt Stocks

Wall Street Journal 06/20/2012

The Egyptian military's role in the economy and government after Mubarak

02/03/2011

The economic crisis facing Egypt after years of underinvestment in the economy.

Grouped Articles

Morsi Faces Ultimatum as Allies Speak of Military ‘Coup’

New York Times 07/01/2013

Fouad Ajami: Egypt on the Brink—With No Clear Way Back

Wall Street Journal 07/02/2013

Egypt's Adly Mansour: Top Judge for Two Days, Now Interim President

Wall Street Journal 07/03/2013

Jurist Sworn In to Lead Egypt Transition

New York Times 07/04/2013

Demoting Democracy in Egypt

New York Times 07/04/2013

U.S. Struggles for Leverage as Mideast Crisis Deepens

Wall Street Journal 07/08/2013

Turkey and Egypt

02/01/2011

The Turkish role in the economic development of Egypt after years of underinvestment in the economy. Turkey's wider role in the development of political institutions for democracy in the Middle East.

Grouped Articles

Turkey Predicts Partnership With Egypt as Regional Anchors

New York Times 09/18/2011

Obama lagging on the Arab Spring - The Washington Post

Washington Post 12/12/2011

Muslim Brotherhood Looks West in Bid to Revive Egyptian Economy

Wall Street Journal 02/17/2012

Muslim Brotherhood Leader Rises as Egypt's Decisive Voice

New York Times 03/12/2012

Egypt’s president is U.S. critic, but could be an ally - The Washington Post

Washington Post 06/26/2012

Turkey Steps Up to the Assad Challenge

Wall Street Journal 06/28/2012


Support LyrArc

We took a different way to help millions around the world build educated informed mindsets that affects and shapes their lives. For a future that is open, global and digital, with everyone having access to high quality information. We believe in the renewal of America, renewal of Europe, the renewal of India, the rest of Asia, Latin America and Africa. The renewal of our supply chains, health, education, infrastructure, as we rebuild our countries after the pandemic. Literacy and knowledge we believe cannot thrive and grow in a world of web bots, web crawlers, or AI. This requires human curiosity, human learning, and human imagination. We take as inspiration the saying- “One has to be free, and as broad as sky. One has to have a mind that is crystal clear, only then can truth shine in it.” Every contribution whether big or small is precious- in this crisis and ahead.

Support Lyrarc from as small as $1


Copyright © 2006 - 2026 Intelilinks LLC
Terms and Conditions | Copyright Policy | Privacy Policy | Contact Us