What happened at BP-TNK appears to be a misjudgement on the part of Hayward, Dudley, Dupree and other BP managers about who counted and to what extent in the Russian government and state run oil companies. Its still clear that Putin and his appointed head of the energy sector Igor Sechin are in charge here. As head of Rosneft the state run oil company and in his role as head of the energy sector Sechin had more influence on the eventual outcome than the lowere ranking Gazprom officials after Medvedev left Gazprom to be President. And Putin may simply have respected Sechin's judgement on the need to keep Rosneft as a significant player in the oil business as Gazprom itself may be becoming too large, to maintain some competitive forces in the state run oil industry as opposed to concentrating everything into one large bureaucratic enterprise. And Sechin, Putin and Medvedev could let AAR do the work of ridding BP of its notions of a large role in controlling Russian oil resources in a combination with Gazprom. At some other point the oligarchs of AAR could be bought out by the state run companies, especially when oil prices were expected to come down, for a much lower cost....