Last week President Sarkozy of France referred to the golden parachutes and executive compensation when their companies were falling apart as"formidable injustice". StJohn got reguator approval for the Novi hospital based on its ability to use profits to support Riverview. St John asked for $10 million management fee from the state of Michigan for Michigan State University to use the hospital for training residents was this excessive for a hospital that was losing money, and could St John have come up with some agreement with Michigan State where they could still have kept Riverview and had support for the loss. The attached graph shows Ascension made $1250 million in 2007 , some of it on investment gains, considering what it did for the bad publicity for St John and for Ascension was closing Riverview the right decision, and was the payment of $1 million to Joseph CEO of St John the right thing to do given his role in closig St John. And did Ascension consider the devastating impact on Detroit of the closure, and its impact also on St John Hospital in the neighborhood bordering Detroit and Grosse Pointe a wealthy Detroit suburb, as the patients who used Riverview now crowded into St John Hospital thus resulting in similiar losses and the loss of patients from Gross Pointe at St John Hospital, creating the possibility of losses at St John Hospital. ...